As for "primary source", that's if you treat ideas as historical artifacts. If you're actually interested in the ideas themselves, a more apt metaphor would be learning obsolete technology. This is sometimes good, but not often. For example, I recently learned how Intel 8080 works, because I wanted to know more about how CPUs work, and modern ones were too complicated for me.
And yes, using word timeless twice in my original post does make the argument appear circular. Works are not timeless because they are timeless (circular indeed!) but because their themes are timeless AND they were the first to thoroughly explore those themes.
And while PG may be unsure of his influences, the more I read his essays the more I see serious traning in philosophy. He's meticulous in defining concepts and using them consistently. That's exactly the problem and goal of post-Wittgenstein philosophy. Sure, the ultimate utility of the field of philosophy is in question. But, to me, the endeavor has a firm role to play in the education of the mind. Math is more precise, but most of us communicate everyday by using concepts. In conversation, though, how do we make sure we're using the same (or similar) concepts with each other? How do we know we're consistent with ourselves in our own concepts?
I can't think of any I'd recommend. What I learned from trying to study philosophy is that the place to look is in other fields."
That said, I agree with his answer to the raq - you'll be better served by doing philosophy in other fields. Still, I think that's a big difference from saying those classics are a waste of time. In learning to abstract concepts, learning from previous struggles isn't a bad way to go. I am agnostic, however, on the best ways to learn how to abstract concepts.
There will never be a shortage of youth that are lost/confused and at the same time coming of age.
Some argue that we should forgo teaching children the classics because newer, somehow more relevant literature with the same message is now available. The point of reading the classics is that these things are timeless, and so reading the work of the first person to write about a certain topic in depth is like reading a primary source. In other words, it should be encouraged in academia.