Re:Peermaps – distributed, offline-friendly alternative to c...
by Tijdreiziger on Sunday September 12, 2021 @08:52AM
(#28500692)
This app looks really great, but I have a few questions...
(1) Where does the online map data come from? From Magic Earth servers or somewhere else?
(2) Where is the 3D data sourced from?
(3) Where is the satellite imagery sourced from? OSM definitely doesn't have this.
(4) Where are transit directions sourced from? AFAIK OSM also can't do this.
(5) Who is behind this app? The privacy policy just refers to them as 'Company'.
All in all, the functionality looks great but I'm quite skeptical about the lack of transparency.
Personally, I prefer Magic Earth. I keep 7 surrounding US states downloaded on my phone and I get notification of updates (every few months).
Average file size per state is about 450MB stored on SD card. It is how maps should be done in my opinion.
The only difference here is how the distribution is handled. Not sure P2P is the way to go since most peers are likely to be mobile devices where data transfer can be disruptive and expensive.