Re:POW Captcha: a lightweight, self-hosted proof-of-work cap...
by d--b on Friday September 10, 2021 @06:03PM
(#28487411)
I don't get this. People can still create 1000s of fake users on my website just by using CPU time?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:POW Captcha: a lightweight, self-hosted proof-of-work cap...
by spijdar on Friday September 10, 2021 @06:20PM
(#28487554)
It's effectively a rate limiter, where before the Bad Person/People could make 10,000 users per unit of time before, now they may only make 100 users. It won't fix the problem entirely, but it's better than nothing.
Re:POW Captcha: a lightweight, self-hosted proof-of-work cap...
by d--b on Friday September 10, 2021 @06:26PM
(#28487593)
But people can still run several sessions of this.
So if I have 100 cores available, I can run 100 sessions in parallel.
Re:POW Captcha: a lightweight, self-hosted proof-of-work cap...
by ReactiveJelly on Friday September 10, 2021 @07:27PM
(#28488001)
See my other comment about auto-scaling. Adjusting difficulty for PoW is trivial. Have the server crank up the challenge if it's getting more traffic than normal.
Re:POW Captcha: a lightweight, self-hosted proof-of-work cap...
by kevincox on Friday September 10, 2021 @07:42PM
(#28488097)
Or base the challenge difficulty based on other parameters. For example if your IP has had a lot of failed login attempts recently the difficulty can be increased.
Re:POW Captcha: a lightweight, self-hosted proof-of-work cap...
by spijdar on Friday September 10, 2021 @06:55PM
(#28487787)
Right, but they still will be slower than if there was no protection at all. 100 slower cores vs 100 cores churning out requests ASAP.
For a determined or resourceful attacker, this alone won't be good enough defense, but I can see it being a layer of defense in depth.
Re:POW Captcha: a lightweight, self-hosted proof-of-work cap...
by wraptile on Saturday September 11, 2021 @03:51AM
(#28490181)
I don't get this. People can still create 1000s of fake users on my website just by _buying captcha solves_?
Type of spent resource is rather irrelevant, isn't it?
Re:POW Captcha: a lightweight, self-hosted proof-of-work cap...
by forestjohnson on Friday September 10, 2021 @10:14PM
(#28488906)
yes, but they cant create 1000s of fake users on EVERY website, unless they wanna shell out millions of dollars per year for the compute power required.