Re:POW Captcha: a lightweight, self-hosted proof-of-work cap...
by sneak on Friday September 10, 2021 @05:59PM
(#28487377)
It fails to be an automated test to tell computers and humans apart, as computers are more than capable of solving proofs of work without human intervention.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:POW Captcha: a lightweight, self-hosted proof-of-work cap...
by jacoblambda on Friday September 10, 2021 @06:06PM
(#28487439)
This is true but so are the existing captchas. Existing captchas are just harvesting training data for Google's self driving vehicles at this point.
With a PoW captcha, it doesn't matter how smart you make your algorithm, it's still going to be slow. With existing systems I'd argue it's probably a lot slower for people than for machines, especially since it's people guessing what a machine thinks people would classify an image as.
This is an easy solution for rate limiting low trust/high risk connections and better software isn't going to magically make it any faster. This has always been what captchas aim to accomplish.
Re:POW Captcha: a lightweight, self-hosted proof-of-work cap...
by Pxtl on Friday September 10, 2021 @07:22PM
(#28487963)
Because we're accepting failure on that front. Instead, it's providing rate-limiting.
Hell, charge me one penny per refresh and a dime per tweet and login attempt. Then let the bots run freely if they're willing to pay that rate.