The people who believe in it are extroverts. They are never in the office, they are walking around looking for people to talk to. The only time they are in their office is when they are have a conversation that truly does need to be private.
The introverts in the mean time need time away from people to recharge. They don't want you interrupting if it isn't an emergency.
The above only works if no-one does it.
Thus open door for the CEO needs to be replaced with something that gets more general feedback. I'm not sure what that might be though.
Whether acknowledged or not, there is a power discrepancy between executives (especially C-suite execs) and everyone else. That discrepancy means that executives can't expect to get the real picture by relying on workers to tell them.
Personally, I’m capable of deep focus but also easily distracted. In some sense it almost physically hurts to be pulled out of that focus. When it happens too often, I’m “scared” to try and get back in.
Putting me in an open floor (as has happened repeatedly in the last decade) is certainly not the key to maximizing my impact.