News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or... by disneygibson on Friday September 10, 2021 @09:23AM (#28481177)
So we should mandate everything that saves lives, no matter the cost to freedom or infringing of rights?

This is the issue with technocratic government: zero understanding of anything deeper than “if it works, do it!”

Re:OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or... by boplicity on Friday September 10, 2021 @09:32AM (#28481273)
I am open to hearing a coherent description of the specific "cost to freedom" of taking one of the widely available COVID vaccines.
Re:OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or... by disneygibson on Friday September 10, 2021 @09:34AM (#28481316)
I don’t think most people have an issue with voluntary vaccination. The problem is when nefarious actors use the situation to create a surveillance state, social credit system, and then exclude people from doing simple human things like eating at a restaurant.

Australia is the future of the Western world.

Re:OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or... by boplicity on Friday September 10, 2021 @10:05AM (#28481746)
> Surveillance state

If that exists, it existed before COVID, and vaccinations against COVID certainly haven't changed that.

> Social credit system

Are you referring to mandates? These have been a thing, in the U.S., for many decades

> exclude people from doing simple human things

Vaccine mandates have excluded people from things far more important than restaurants, such as education, for many decades. This is not new to COVID.

You seem to be arguing against a system that has existed for many, many years.

Re:OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or... by _-david-_ on Friday September 10, 2021 @05:15PM (#28486973)
>If that exists, it existed before COVID, and vaccinations against COVID certainly haven't changed that.

Australia is taking it to the next level and using covid as an excuse. Do you believe that they will end their programs in 5 years when all of this is over?

>Are you referring to mandates? These have been a thing, in the U.S., for many decades

Vaccine passports are starting to be required to go to concerts, grocery stores, ball games, etc. If you do not do what the state wants you to do you will become a second class citizen with restrictions. This is similar to the social credit system in China.

>Vaccine mandates have excluded people from things far more important than restaurants, such as education, for many decades. This is not new to COVID.

No one is restricted from education. You can go to a private school or get an exemption.

Re:OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or... by disneygibson on Friday September 10, 2021 @10:07AM (#28481783)
Most of the new things didn’t exist before. This is…basic information.

Even if they did, it’s pretty obvious that they have been dramatically increased in the last 18 months.

You seem extremely uninformed.

Re:OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or... by boplicity on Friday September 10, 2021 @10:12AM (#28481830)
For example, requiring almost everyone to get a vaccine? That's not new. That's been happening for decades.

The only difference is there's a new vaccine that needs to be rolled out to everyone, as quickly as possible.

Most people get their mandatory vaccines as children, in a staggered way.

Because of the current situation, it's happening all at once, and the restrictions that enforce the vaccine are also being changed, based on the age of the people required to get the vaccine. What am I missing here?

Re:OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or... by disneygibson on Friday September 10, 2021 @10:14AM (#28481854)
When was it common to prevent people from entering a restaurant unless they were vaccinated with a vaccine that itself had only been developed 15 months prior?
Re:OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or... by boplicity on Friday September 10, 2021 @11:03AM (#28482562)
Apparently, in the past, the Supreme Court even allowed knocking down people's doors in order to force vaccinations.

"That was a relatively easy no for the court. In a 7-2 ruling in Jacobson vs. Massachusetts, it decided that jurisdictions do have the right to require people to get vaccinated. Back then, the government was much more forceful about it, knocking down people’s doors to get them vaccinated, the New York Times says."

https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2021/09/10/republica...

Denying access to restaurants seems....timid? At least, in comparison.

Re:OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or... by TechBro8615 on Friday September 10, 2021 @11:55AM (#28483310)
This meme about “Jacobson vs. Massachusetts” doesn’t seem as strong an argument as the useful idiots believe. It’s an example of the court affirming the right of a State Legislature. It says nothing about the right of the executive branch of the federal government to forbid private transactions between employers and employees, unless the employee submits to a medical procedure mandated by executive order.

I’m sure the argument falls apart in many other ways. You can probably find the counter arguments in the same Twitter thread where you found your talking points – just make sure to unhide the tweets containing them.

Re:OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or... by jbeam on Friday September 10, 2021 @12:35PM (#28483914)
The poster above was replying to a comment about mandates to enter restaurants. Those mandates have been entirely state directed. So it does not fall apart at all.
Re:OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or... by boplicity on Friday September 10, 2021 @12:53PM (#28484194)
In terms of Biden's recent mandate announcements, that would be two questions:

1. Is OSHA legal?

2. Is the mandate within OSHA's scope?

In terms of state level mandates, the Jacobson vs. Massachusetts ruling clearly applies.

Re:OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or... by boplicity on Friday September 10, 2021 @10:52AM (#28482391)
You're comparing denying education to children to denying non-essential services, such as restaurants, to adults. One is an essential right, the other is not.

If anything the restrictions people are putting in place to enforce the vaccine mandate have been less extreme. As workplace mandates get rolled out, this will become more even, as the right to work is comparable to the right to an education.

As I tried to communicate before, curtailing basic rights in order to enforce vaccinations for everyone is not new. The only difference is that these usually happen based on age, instead of happening to everyone, all at once.

Re:OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or... by betwixthewires on Friday September 10, 2021 @12:48PM (#28484109)
There's no cost to freedom to taking it. There's a cost to freedom to be coerced into taking it.
Re:OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or... by tomrod on Friday September 10, 2021 @09:29AM (#28481245)
It's been a year this approach has been claimed.

Time to roll up sleeves for your civic duty.

Re:OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or... by ImPostingOnHN on Friday September 10, 2021 @09:37AM (#28481354)
As in most such trade-offs, the "cost to freedom" and "infringing of rights", to the extent they actually exist, factor into the cost/benefit decision of whether or not to ultimately go through with the mandate

since everybody has their own opinion on where that balance is, there will always be individuals unhappy with what decision makers decide

Re:OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or... by disneygibson on Friday September 10, 2021 @09:46AM (#28481485)
No, that isn’t how rights work. They are guarantees that cannot be violated, no matter how democratically popular they are.
Re:OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or... by ImPostingOnHN on Friday September 10, 2021 @10:17AM (#28481888)
aside from the trade-off discussion above, it looks like you also have opinions about the constitutionality of this move

it is, of course, totally okay to have an opinion on that, but an opinion does not necessarily grant decision power, or even veto power, so ultimately you aren't the one who gets to decide what constitutes a right, and you aren't the one who gets to decide what constitutes a violation or an infringement of a right

I'm not trying to slam you here, because I am also not the one who gets to decide that -- I'm just one of hundreds of millions of Americans, the majority of which do not have a problem with this move

now, of course, if someone/you believes this move is an unconstitutional violation of rights, they/you can bring it to SCOTUS, who will let them/you know if they/you are right

and if SCOTUS does ultimately say that this specific mandate is unconstitutional, then of course I agree with you that such a decision should be respected unless and until We The People change the constitution, which would be okay, too

Re:OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or... by disneygibson on Friday September 10, 2021 @10:20AM (#28481921)
No I’m simply rejecting your framing of the discussion. Rights are not a question of votes. It is not up for deciding democratically. To frame the question this way is to fundamentally misunderstand how rights work.
Re:OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or... by ImPostingOnHN on Friday September 10, 2021 @10:22AM (#28481954)
your framing is that anything you say is a right/violation/infringement is one

that framing does not reflect reality

if and when a SCOTUS ruling says that this specific mandate is a violation of constitutional rights, you will be correct

until then, you are not correct, by default

otherwise any random dude on the internet could just declare _anything_ a "right" and declare _anything_ an "infringement"

I still respect you as a person, though -- have a great day

Re:OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or... by disneygibson on Friday September 10, 2021 @10:23AM (#28481974)
It has nothing to do with SCOTUS specifically.

I can’t keep repeating the same thing over and over again.

Re:OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or... by ImPostingOnHN on Friday September 10, 2021 @10:24AM (#28481995)
it does -- SCOTUS is the one who will decide whether or not you are correct when claiming this move is a violation or an infringement on constitutional rights

I can't keep repeating the same thing over and over again

Re:OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or... by TechBro8615 on Friday September 10, 2021 @11:58AM (#28483355)
Just to be extra clear — the constitution does not grant rights. It acknowledges rights that were “endowed by our creator.” They exist by default, and they… oh, you know, the thing…
Re:OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or... by dragonwriter on Friday September 10, 2021 @12:40PM (#28483982)
> Just to be extra clear — the constitution does not grant rights

Just to be clear, it absolutely does establish such rights in law and thereby grant them as legal rights. It may be that some of authors and ratifiers (and some current constituents) of the Constitution have a (quasi- or literally) religious belief about the metaphysical preexistence of and/or independent ethical universal necessity of exactly such rights (or a super- or subset of them) against any legitimate government, but that's...largely immaterial except in terms of arguments between people sharing such views as to what rights should be established in law, or social science analysis of why the particular rights chosen were established in the Constitution.

Re:OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or... by amanaplanacanal on Friday September 10, 2021 @12:29PM (#28483845)
That is certainly one theory of government, but it is not the only one, or probably even the most popular one. For instance, we have many laws that infringe free speech rights, and the great majority of people are perfectly fine with that. Your platonic ideal of “rights” isn’t the way rights actually work in the real world.
Re:OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or... by dragonwriter on Friday September 10, 2021 @12:35PM (#28483919)
> For instance, we have many laws that infringe free speech rights, and the great majority of people are perfectly fine with that.

I think you'll find that most people who are okay with the laws you are referencing likewise disagree that those laws infringe free speech rights, rather, they view them as operating in a space outside of the proper conception of the right to free speech; the complexity isn't as much in the operation of rights as in the parameters of rights.

Re:OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or... by ImPostingOnHN on Friday September 10, 2021 @12:42PM (#28484022)
let me weigh in as one of the above sample points to say, that sounds like "sometimes that right can be infringed" with more words, which yeah, I am okay with

an alternate interpretation with the exact same implications might be "that right isn't absolute", which, yeah, I am okay with

ultimately it's just semantics that fails to meaningfully address GP's comment

Re:OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or... by dragonwriter on Friday September 10, 2021 @12:47PM (#28484097)
It's critically different.

If, as real property analogy, I have fee simple title to a parcel part of which is subject to utility easement, the utility company’s access within the scope of the easement is not an infringement of my right of exclusive control, it is outside of the scope of that right.

Similarly, most people who support laws that you see as “infringing” on the right of free speech who agree that a right with that name exists view the definition of the scope of that right more narrowly than the people who see the law as an infringement.

Re:OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or... by ImPostingOnHN on Friday September 10, 2021 @12:49PM (#28484136)
you've twice said "most people" don't view the "fire in a theater" analogy to be a limitation on a right,

yet here I am, one of those people, telling you that yes, I do indeed view it as one

Re:OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or... by dragonwriter on Friday September 10, 2021 @12:56PM (#28484256)
> you've twice said "most people" don't view the "fire in a theater" analogy to be a limitation on a right,

No, I haven't.

In fact, I’ve said nothing in this thread about that analogy (and nothing at all about it, IIRC, on HN except [in summary form] that it has fuck-all to do with the actual law, either now or when it originally appeared as dicta in an abomination of a decision.)

Nor have I said anything about what “most people” view as a “limitation” on a right. What I’ve said is about that most people who support a given law that others characterize as an “infringement” of the right do bot view it as an infringement, but as an act outside the scope of the meaning of the right.

> yet here I am, one of those people

Even if literally everything you said preceding this wasn't false, “one” ≠ “most”, except in a particular degenerate case where it is also “all”.

Re:OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or... by ImPostingOnHN on Friday September 10, 2021 @01:01PM (#28484331)
so far, of the data you've presented plus the data we see here, the sample size is 1, me, and 100% of respondents disagree with your proposition, so it's unclear where you are getting "most" from -- but let's ignore all that and grant you the point for now

if I am understanding you correctly, you are saying there is a difference between society viewing something as outside the boundaries of a right, versus society viewing something as an allowed, permitted-by-society infringement on a right

if we assume that is true, then what are the implications to OP's post?

e.g. the vaccination mandate can be presented as either "outside the boundaries of the right" for whatever right those protesting the mandate cite, or an allowed, permitted-by-society infringement on that right

so what's the difference?

Re:OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or... by betwixthewires on Friday September 10, 2021 @01:15PM (#28484517)
"We violate rights therefore it is fine to violate rights"

The whole idea of rights is that they cannot be violated, period. There's no reason to even have for example a UN Declaration on Human Rights if they can just be violated for Good Reasons™. Rights are absolute or they don't exist.

Re:OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or... by amanaplanacanal on Friday September 10, 2021 @01:23PM (#28484621)
By your logic then they don’t exist. There is no place in the world that rights have been absolute, and there never has been.
Re:OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or... by betwixthewires on Friday September 10, 2021 @01:27PM (#28484666)
You miss my point. It doesn't matter if it has never happened, that just means we have failed ourselves. What matters is defining the concept of rights, exploring what they mean and what they are. I'm not talking about if they exist in practice in any specific country, I'm talking about "what are rights?"

Rights are things reserved for individuals to hold unilaterally, sovereign over them, no democratic process or other consideration can take them away. That's the whole idea. That's at the core of the definition of the concept. Without that, the concept of rights doesn't exist.