News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New math book rescues landmark topology proof by CamperBob2 on Thursday September 09, 2021 @05:42PM (#28475011)
The most recent case similar to this one is Mochizuki's work on the ABC conjecture, which has still not reached the point where it's accepted by the majority of the community due to its complexity. There are lots of parallels between Mochizuki and Freedman. They both had to break a lot of new ground, and they both had trouble communicating their results to enough people to become part of the official canon of mathematics that can actually be taught to others.

Freedman at least convinced a few key people, but AFAIK Mochizuki's work has never been understood by anyone not named Mochizuki. It may be complete BS, it may be earthshakingly brilliant, but either way it will evidently take someone's entire career to prove it.

Re:New math book rescues landmark topology proof by iainmerrick on Thursday September 09, 2021 @06:03PM (#28475179)
I believe the latest news on Mochizuki’s work is that Peter Scholze and Jakob Stix identified a fatal flaw, and Mochizuki has not convincingly rebutted it. See e.g. the first item here: https://www.math.columbia.edu/~woit/wordpress/?p=12429

Both the claimed proof and the disproof have now been published in journals, and neither has been retracted! That’s a rather unusual situation to say the least. But I think people in the field generally agree that the proof is flawed and unfixable.

Re:New math book rescues landmark topology proof by ntlang on Thursday September 09, 2021 @06:26PM (#28475387)
Experts have been skeptical for quite some time. You can see discussion on the exact point Scholze (PS) brings up in the following blog post (the post and many comments are by prominent number theorists)

https://www.galoisrepresentations.com/2017/12/17/the-abc-con...

One quote from the post I find worth repeating:

> This post is not about making epistemological claims about the truth or otherwise of Mochizuki’s arguments. To take an extreme example, if Mochizuki had carved his argument on slate in Linear A and then dropped it into the Mariana Trench, then there would be little doubt that asking about the veracity of the argument would be beside the point. The reality, however, is that this description is not so far from the truth.