Re:Thoughts on Clojure UI framework
by brundolf on Thursday September 09, 2021 @02:08PM
(#28472741)
What? The Apple Music desktop app is native, built with Catalyst (and is awful despite that)
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Thoughts on Clojure UI framework
by marcellus23 on Thursday September 09, 2021 @03:19PM
(#28473554)
It is not built with Catalyst. Podcasts is, but Music is not. And presumably he's referring to the webview-based parts of Apple Music, i.e. the browsing piece of it. The native parts of the app (library browsing and management) work very well in my experience.
If I'm wrong I'll stand corrected but, it behaves way too much like a web app to not at least be making heavy use of WKWebView.
What does "behaves too much like a web app" even mean in this context?
If you go to something like the For You screen, you will see a pause while the content is loaded remotely. And if you hit Command-R, it will reload, like a web page.
I think the other commenters are right that Music.app is written as a native macOS app, but it definitely leans heavily on web views for content, especially in the streaming parts of the app.
Like it's broken beyond all recognition and hope with all interactions and expectations of a native app just gone. See this review: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gE8ZikfrpFU
Native and yet still sucks. Most catalyst apps suck.