It's a self-reinforcing cycle
amazon is bad -> therefore when amazon does something good, it's bad -> amazon is bad -> ...
The American reaction to a Russian SALT treaty during the Cold War is one well-known example of naïve cynicism in history. Political leaders negotiating on behalf of the United States discredited the offer simply because it was proposed by the Russian side.[1][9]
Former U.S. congressman Floyd Spence indicates the use of naïve cynicism in this quote:
"I have had a philosophy for some time in regard to SALT, and it goes like this: the Russians will not accept a SALT treaty that is not in their best interest, and it seems to me that if it is their best interests, it can‘t be in our best interest."
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Na%C3%AFve_cynicism...it's the epitome of bias.
> You assume everything good is done in bad faith by people you've labelled "bad" and then judged them to be bad based on acts you've assumed were done in bad faith.
I assume what Amazon does is bad by default, but I'm perfectly willing to accept that it's good if I'm proven otherwise (maybe someone convinces me, or I do my own research and come to that conclusion). I'm just always going to assume the worst, and that's going to put them at a permanent disadvantage when competing for my patronage. That's like, peak capitalism: penalize bad behavior through the market.
Idk why I need to explain this, since I'm pretty sure everyone understands the concept of a reputation. Is it "intellectually lazy" to not invite a registered sex offender to your child's birthday party? This is basically the same thing, but less dramatic.
It reminds me of the protesters happy to destroy other people's property, but then signal outrage when their own property is destroyed.
Plus, again, I'm talking about corporations, not people. Corporations are not people. For example, Microsoft is a rotten company and I will never be their customer if I can avoid it. But I have absolutely nothing against Microsoft's employees (except maybe some of the C suite)
[1] https://nypost.com/2020/05/01/jeff-bezos-may-have-lied-to-co...
[2] https://www.bookweb.org/news/aba-releases-report-detailing-a...
[3] https://time.com/5629233/amazon-warehouse-employee-treatment...
[4] https://www.msn.com/en-us/money/companies/biden-singles-out-...
You've never lied? If someone found a lie you once said and put it in a comment like this, what would it signify?
I'm pretty sure Amazon doesn't always lie, just like you don't always lie.
> and cheat[2]
Same sentiment as above.
> and try to exploit everyone in my life[3]
Pretty sure Amazon doesn't try to exploit everyone. Lots of Amazon employees feel that way too.
> Hell, I even pay my taxes![4]
You don't take deductions when you can? If you do, how are you different from Amazon?
As an example, for years, I never deducted charitable contributions even though I could. How about mortgage interest?
Unless you willingly do not take tax deductions that you are eligible for, I don't see a difference between your behavior and theirs.
You are a complex person, as is a company like Amazon. Throwing absolutist statements about them is as problematic as throwing absolutist statements about you.
You don't see how that attitude, if held by more people, creates the situation it holds in contempt?
If I'm working with someone who responds like that to acts of goodwill, I don't have an incentive to be nice. Being a human, I'll likely be spiteful. (And goodwill doesn't have to be purely altruistic to be good. Win-wins exist.)
Does it really matter that giving employees benefits like this is in Amazon's best interest when it is also in the interests of the employees themselves? Should we decry Amazon providing warehouse workers with a parking lot as some cynical ploy to get workers to come to work?
Not every benefit given to employees is bad just because it also benefits the company.
I assume, in this case, there are tax benefits and that Amazon gets a cut of revenue.
https://www.wolterskluwer.com/en/expert-insights/furthering-...
"As the employer, you may deduct the entire amount that you pay for the employee's educational costs as a business expense. However, only $5,250 is not considered wages and therefore, not subject to payroll taxes. Amounts over the annual limit are subject to income and payroll taxes."
Because the benefit of the doubt is for people/companies who haven't repeatedly (some might even say enthusiastically) shown that they don't deserve it.
At this point, it's always safe to assume ulterior motives anytime Amazon does something that seems good.