Re:We Could Brighten Clouds to Cool the Earth
by throwaway894345 on Thursday September 09, 2021 @12:09PM
(#28471251)
I agree, though it seems reasonable to trial it at a small scale as soon as possible so we can gradually scale it up and understand these second and third order effects with minimal risk.
Re:We Could Brighten Clouds to Cool the Earth
by smu on Thursday September 09, 2021 @01:08PM
(#28471986)
Agree, it’s the only way for us to test our assumptions.
I wonder how well the experimentation approach will work in this case though, as:
1. Effects might be subtle and outside of the expected impact area.
2. Timescale might be really important (effects over a time much longer than we anticipate. Or even a timescale that makes it impossible to run many experiments in reasonable time)
Re:We Could Brighten Clouds to Cool the Earth
by throwaway894345 on Thursday September 09, 2021 @04:13PM
(#28474125)
I think this is a general argument that you can make about any risky enterprise (e.g., GMOs, vaccines, etc). There's always the possibility that your testing is inadequate, you can never drive risk to 0, etc. But by starting small and scaling up very gradually (while studying carefully the whole time) you maximize the risk that you will find and mitigate problems early and "cheaply" (i.e., without committing to applying the technique to the entire world).
Anyway, the idea is to have an ace in the hole in case we run out of other options to reduce climate change--at that point, the question is "which is less risky, geo-engineering or runaway climate change?".
Re:We Could Brighten Clouds to Cool the Earth
by karaterobot on Thursday September 09, 2021 @02:53PM
(#28473223)
As these things go, it's the lowest risk play I'm aware of. You can use it in a fairly specific area, like for example over a melting ice sheet. If you stop actively using it, the droplets precipitate out after a week or two, and everything goes back to the way it was. The biggest drawback, in fact, is that it is not permanent.
Re:We Could Brighten Clouds to Cool the Earth
by GekkePrutser on Thursday September 09, 2021 @06:09PM
(#28475231)
Dropping salt on a melting ice sheet does not sound like a great plan.
We'd really need to invest in really detailed computer models to make sure we're not overlooking something and shooting ourselves in the foot, IMO.
Re:We Could Brighten Clouds to Cool the Earth
by karaterobot on Thursday September 09, 2021 @11:51PM
(#28477616)
Well, if civilization was destroyed by spraying a fine mist of sea water into the air from the back of a boat, I guess I would feel pretty bad. But, that seems highly unlikely, and certainly less likely than that we'll destroy ourselves by continuing to do absolutely nothing to stop the climate from collapsing.
Seems like a high risk play, only to use as a last resort to me.