News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Quantum mechanics and our part in creating reality by jonathanstrange on Thursday September 09, 2021 @11:30AM (#28470775)
Wait a minute. As a non-physicist who only knows QM from popular science texts, I always thought that wave function collapse does not require any human intervention and that this can be shown. Isn't "measurement" just an interaction of one physical system with another? If so, why would anyone include subjective degrees of belief in a formulation of QM?

Could a physicist please clarify this?

Re:Quantum mechanics and our part in creating reality by monktastic1 on Thursday September 09, 2021 @11:33AM (#28470814)
When one system measures another, there is no collapse, only entanglement. The superposition just grows. As trillions of environmental particles entangle with the system, that superposition becomes in practice -- but not in principle -- impossible to detect or exploit. This is called decoherence, and it is often wrongly used to explain away the issue.

When does "collapse" happen in principle? There's no clear answer. Yet, when you observe a system yourself, you are free to say it has one result (at least, in "your world / branch" if we use MWI lingo). So there is (possibly) a sense in which you are the only observer -- at least, w.r.t. the place you think of as "the world."

(And of course when we say "you observe," we mean "you experience". If only your toe measures it, you may treat your toe as an external measuring device. This is how "consciousness" enters the picture, though nobody agrees on what exactly it means.)

Re:Quantum mechanics and our part in creating reality by rkagerer on Thursday September 09, 2021 @03:08PM (#28473422)
If only your toe measures it, you may treat your toe as an external measuring device.

But from the viewpoint of the toe would it have collapsed?

Extrapolating that, why isn't your consciousness just another measuring device that's become entangled with the system?

Re:Quantum mechanics and our part in creating reality by monktastic1 on Thursday September 09, 2021 @04:21PM (#28474192)
Yes, if you assume the toe has "a viewpoint," then from its viewpoint, things have collapsed. But as you are not your toe, this has no observable consequence for you. It's pure philosophy.

Similarly, your consciousness could be considered just another measuring device from the perspective of someone outside the system. But by virtue of being "outside the system," their results have no bearing on you either.

You are the point at which "the magic happens" in your world -- which is just the place you normally call "the" world. It is the point at which neither you nor anyone else you can communicate with (i.e., no one else in "the world") can demonstrate interference, even in principle.

Re:Quantum mechanics and our part in creating reality by phkahler on Thursday September 09, 2021 @12:10PM (#28471253)
>> When does "collapse" happen in principle? There's no clear answer.

It does not happen at all. There is no measurable distinction between a particle whose wave function has collapsed and one that hasn't. If there were a discernable difference the "spooky action at a distance" when an entangled pair is collapsed could be used for faster than light communication.

>> When one system measures another, there is no collapse, only entanglement.

This is the first time I've seen this explanation. To me it feels like an attempt at resolving the issue, but I think not.

The right answer AFAICT is that we must embrace non-locality. But that's still another sort of punt.

Re:Quantum mechanics and our part in creating reality by monktastic1 on Thursday September 09, 2021 @12:30PM (#28471505)
I put "collapse" in quotes for a reason. There is an experimentally verifiable distinction between a particle in superposition (w.r.t a particular basis) and one that is not. Both theory and experiment give us every reason to believe that prior to your observation, you can exhibit the superposition through an interference experiment (modulo decoherence), while afterward you cannot (even if "God" still can).

Also, this surprises me (assuming you studied QM formally):

> This is the first time I've seen this explanation.

Entanglement is basically the definition of measurement (in this context).

Re:Quantum mechanics and our part in creating reality by kgwgk on Thursday September 09, 2021 @03:36PM (#28473728)
I’m not sure of what is your context but that unitary interaction is just the first step (also called pre-measurement) in von Neumann’s model of measurement.
Re:Quantum mechanics and our part in creating reality by monktastic1 on Thursday September 09, 2021 @04:23PM (#28474223)
Indeed. The context here is:

> As a non-physicist who only knows QM from popular science texts, I always thought that wave function collapse does not require any human intervention and that this can be shown.

When pop sci treatments explain that any physical system interacting with the apparatus "measures" it, they are just talking about what you call "pre-measurement." This causes a lot of confusion for students.

Re:Quantum mechanics and our part in creating reality by kgwgk on Thursday September 09, 2021 @04:56PM (#28474554)
I agree, I think. The observed “collapse” is not completely explained by decoherence (and even less satisfactory by many worlds).
Re:Quantum mechanics and our part in creating reality by dekhn on Thursday September 09, 2021 @11:53AM (#28471049)
QM works even if there are no humans or other subjective "observers". Any theory of QM that involves subjective observers for wavefunction collapse is quantum woo.
Re:Quantum mechanics and our part in creating reality by drdec on Thursday September 09, 2021 @01:29PM (#28472264)
Maybe it's a clever hack.

Suppose you are making a universe. You want to ensure that the universe you make is interesting, i.e. contains consciousness. So you set up the rules like QM: everything exists in probabilistic superposition until a consciousness observes it. One of the superpositions contains a consciousness, and that collapses the wavefunction guaranteeing consciousness in your universe. It's a way of using survivor bias in your favor.

Disclaimer: not to be taken seriously.

Disclaimer #2: Also, coincidentally, not related to poster drdeca. Unless he is me from another superposition and we haven't collapsed yet because you all are not as conscious as you think.

Re:Quantum mechanics and our part in creating reality by dekhn on Thursday September 09, 2021 @01:43PM (#28472450)
I see no value in speculating about how the universe was made, nor relating that to quantum mechanics, without have extensive data, and none of the data we have today supports making any of these kinds of speculations.
Re:Quantum mechanics and our part in creating reality by soultrees on Thursday September 09, 2021 @11:27PM (#28477490)
Without speculation, how else would you know what to measure against?
Re:Quantum mechanics and our part in creating reality by drdeca on Thursday September 09, 2021 @12:12PM (#28471290)
The former doesn’t imply the latter.

I suspect one could think of QBism as a theory of rational belief for agents in a context where details of quantum mechanics are highly relevant.

Just as bayesianism is a theory of rational belief more generally.

Re:Quantum mechanics and our part in creating reality by dekhn on Thursday September 09, 2021 @12:39PM (#28471616)
the former implies the latter through occam's razor.
Re:Quantum mechanics and our part in creating reality by vankessel on Thursday September 09, 2021 @02:44PM (#28473120)
I don't disagree with you, but Occam's razor is a principle; a guideline. Not a hard law. From the panpsychic perspective all matter is conscious making everything a "subjective observer," which solves the same problem of humans being arbitrary special observers. Unprovable philosophical dead-end? Sure. Woo? Nah.
Re:Quantum mechanics and our part in creating reality by dekhn on Thursday September 09, 2021 @03:17PM (#28473540)
this is why I said "implies". I fully acknowledge that in principle QM and human minds might be intimately boundm but that, like panpsychism is effectively ipossible to prove or disprove in our current scientific framework.
Re:Quantum mechanics and our part in creating reality by drdeca on Thursday September 09, 2021 @01:15PM (#28472075)
I don’t follow.

Perhaps we are using “theory of” in different ways?

Re:Quantum mechanics and our part in creating reality by dekhn on Thursday September 09, 2021 @01:33PM (#28472323)
Probably. I'm using the technical, scientific definition.
Re:Quantum mechanics and our part in creating reality by drdeca on Thursday September 09, 2021 @02:35PM (#28473037)
What I mean is, “technical account/description of”
Re:Quantum mechanics and our part in creating reality by dekhn on Thursday September 09, 2021 @03:56PM (#28473955)
Scientific theories are explanations for ("why"), not passive descriptions.
Re:Quantum mechanics and our part in creating reality by drdeca on Thursday September 09, 2021 @07:04PM (#28475743)
I don’t know quite what you mean by this.
Re:Quantum mechanics and our part in creating reality by codethief on Thursday September 09, 2021 @01:29PM (#28472253)
> QM works even if there are no humans or other subjective "observers".

How do you know?

Re:Quantum mechanics and our part in creating reality by dekhn on Thursday September 09, 2021 @01:44PM (#28472455)
because the vast majority of data we have excludes it, and it seems really implausible, and gives humans (which are just meatbags) special status.
Re:Quantum mechanics and our part in creating reality by codethief on Thursday September 09, 2021 @08:17PM (#28476307)
> it seems really implausible, and gives humans (which are just meatbags) special status

I agree! However:

> because the vast majority of data we have excludes it

No it doesn't. In fact, there is not a single experimental result that rules this out and I doubt one could ever devise such an experiment in the first place.

All experimental results are consistent with the observer modeling the universe with the Schrödinger equation (i.e. with unitary time evolution / without collapse) and assuming that a measurement by said observer makes the wave function collapse to the appropriate eigenstate.

Re:Quantum mechanics and our part in creating reality by Jensson on Thursday September 09, 2021 @11:36AM (#28470852)
Exactly what is required to cause it to collapse is still not a solved problem. But no, it isn't humans causing it, since it alters the state you can see that it happened afterwards in a system and systems works the same regardless if humans watch them or not.
Re:Quantum mechanics and our part in creating reality by TchoBeer on Thursday September 09, 2021 @11:38AM (#28470876)
>since it alters the state you can see that it happened afterwards in a system

What experiment shows this?

Re:Quantum mechanics and our part in creating reality by simiones on Thursday September 09, 2021 @12:45PM (#28471707)
The version of the double-slit experiment with a detector on one of the slits can be taken to show this.

As you know, in the classical double-slit experiment, the screen is the only detector, and launching particles even one at a time through the slits produces the interference pattern.

However, if you add a second detector in one of the slits capable of measuring if a particle passes through that slit or not, the interference pattern on the screen disappears, regardless of how many particles you send through.

This is normally taken to mean that the slit detector collapses the wave function (in Copenhagen parlance); or that one particular state of the particle becomes entangled with the initial detector, which is already entangled with the screen, to there is no more constructive interference to be seen (in Many Worlds terms).

Re:Quantum mechanics and our part in creating reality by dekhn on Thursday September 09, 2021 @01:28PM (#28472243)
I believe you're referring to delayed choice quantum eraser?
Re:Quantum mechanics and our part in creating reality by simiones on Friday September 10, 2021 @03:44AM (#28478793)
No, that's a different, more complex experiment. This is just about adding a detector to one of the slits so you can tell which slit each electron is passing through.

Here is a more complete explanation:

https://phys.org/news/2011-01-which-way-detector-mystery-dou...

The delayed choice quantum eraser is a much more complex experiment.

Re:Quantum mechanics and our part in creating reality by Jensson on Thursday September 09, 2021 @11:42AM (#28470923)
Re:Quantum mechanics and our part in creating reality by gbrown on Thursday September 09, 2021 @11:55AM (#28471071)
> what is required to cause it to collapse is still not a solved problem

From what I've read, the existence of "collapse" of the wave-function is not established, and not even widely accepted as more than a useful computational tool by practicing physicists.

Re:Quantum mechanics and our part in creating reality by superposeur on Thursday September 09, 2021 @12:55PM (#28471820)
Yes, most physicists agree that human observers are not required to collapse a wave function. Even the QBists speak of “agents” that are abstract entities, not necessarily human beings. (An agent is something like a “point of view” or a “reference frame” in that it can be thought to exist independently of a living, breathing human who inhabits it.) However, n.b. that the great Nobelist Eugene Wigner did seriously think it had to be an actual human consciousness. (Or a dog, but not an insect.)

Full disclosure that I’ve never really been able to pin down the QBist notion of an agent myself and do not find QBism (or any such “instrumentalist” interpretations” of QM) appealing.

Re:Quantum mechanics and our part in creating reality by dekhn on Thursday September 09, 2021 @01:27PM (#28472234)
their use of the terminology of agent is wrong. agents have the ability to make their own decisions independently. Reference frames are just mathematical coordinate conversions, not agents.
Re:Quantum mechanics and our part in creating reality by kgwgk on Thursday September 09, 2021 @02:31PM (#28472996)
> Even the QBists speak of “agents” that are abstract entities,

Do you have a reference for that?

Re:Quantum mechanics and our part in creating reality by cosmophany on Friday September 10, 2021 @10:30AM (#28482066)
A reference is points 17 and 18 in [https://arxiv.org/abs/1810.13401]

Long story short, QBism inherits "agent" from Bayesian decision theory. In that context, we talk about gamblers making bets on the outcomes of dice rolls. In QBism, we talk about scientists making bets on the outcomes of measurements. What exactly can be a "gambler?" Can a dog gamble? What about a trained dog? Or a flea? The answer is: if the shoe fits, wear it. Same goes for QBism. If a dog walks into a lab, lights up a pipe, scribbles equations on the blackboard and starts aligning beamsplitters, then QBism regards him as an agent.

Re:Quantum mechanics and our part in creating reality by kgwgk on Friday September 10, 2021 @01:30PM (#28484710)
A dog is not something like a “point of view” or a “reference frame” in that it can be thought to exist independently of a living, breathing being.

A personalistic interpretation requires a "person". Would a rock or a cell phone qualify as a person? I'm not even sure the authors of that reference would accept a dog, despite saying the concept is extremely flexible (they discuss agents "social" agents but not "dumb" agents).

It's not clear to me that the mathematical description can exist independently of the agent that has some knowledge, for some definition of agent. Even if it can be make to work with no-one's "abstract knowledge" what would be the physical meaning of that? (Not that the physical meaning when agents are present is clear, to be fair.)

Re:Quantum mechanics and our part in creating reality by cosmophany on Friday September 10, 2021 @10:14AM (#28481855)
(physicist here). I think monktastic1 mostly nailed it, I just want to add some further clarifications.

Take the electron double-slit experiment. Suppose no human checks which slit the electron goes through, but the "which-path" information leaks out into the environment somehow. The interference fringes will be destroyed anyway (called "environmental decoherence").

This is usually framed by saying "oh look, the environment measured the system". In fact, what happened is that (1) you prepared what you believed to be an electron beam in a coherent superposition; (2) you left it open to the environment; (3) you used quantum theory to model the system-plus-environment and predicted that you would not see interference fringes when you check; (4) YOU observed the dots on the glass plate and confirmed that there were no interference fringes. The whole story is told in terms of what YOU believed, expected, and finally what you saw. That is QBism's whole point.

Put it another way: in QBism wavefunctions just ARE sets of probability assignments to certain actual events that could be observed. And probabilities are human constructions: we invented them to help us reason about our expectations. So, without humans (or other beings capable of reasoning about expectations), there are no probabilities, hence no wavefunctions either. But stuff still happens, even when there's nobody around to see it or assign probabilities to it.

The key conceptual leap is separating "wavefunction" completely from "reality". There's more to quantum physics than just the wavefunctions -- the reality lies in the events that happen, not in the quantum state itself.

Re:Quantum mechanics and our part in creating reality by wizzwizz4 on Thursday September 09, 2021 @01:27PM (#28472230)
> I always thought that wave function collapse does not require any human intervention and that this can be shown.

It is, in principle, impossible to determine this, because eventually humans will see the output of the experiments. However, we can say that if humans are special, the only things able to cause “measurement”, then our specialness also gives us time travel powers that can only be used for “measurement”, and Occam's Razor says that's probably nonsense.

Re:Quantum mechanics and our part in creating reality by MrYellowP on Thursday September 09, 2021 @04:49PM (#28474478)
> then our specialness also gives us time travel powers

Why? Because the Quantum Eraser Experiment comes out as it does?

Re:Quantum mechanics and our part in creating reality by wizzwizz4 on Friday September 10, 2021 @08:14AM (#28480429)
The delayed choice quantum eraser experiment works too, but I was thinking of a two-channel (CHSH) Bell test where the observations are made separated by a few light-minutes, then later compared with each other (and somehow you eliminate enough noise that you don't need a coincidence monitor).
Re:Quantum mechanics and our part in creating reality by joeberon on Thursday September 09, 2021 @01:19PM (#28472144)
> Isn't "measurement" just an interaction of one physical system with another?

We don't have an accepted theory on what "measurement" is in Quantum Mechanics yet.