Re:MIT-designed project achieves major advance toward fusion...
by ben_w on Thursday September 09, 2021 @04:30AM
(#28467534)
I believe the two of you are talking about different things.
The argument in the UCSD blog post linked above will apply to any finite system if you assume exponential growth in power use, and exponential beats cubic for expansion to other worlds (I’m assuming no FTL for a cubic limit to expansion).
Abundant power — be it from fusion or solar or quantum magic — does not actually need to guarantee eternal exponential growth of power use, but the absence of such growth would necessarily lead eventually to the absence of economic growth.
We can still have a SciFi future without that, it will just look different in a way our current society can’t properly envision (which I think is an unsurprising a claim to make even in the absence of the rest of this argument).
The argument in the UCSD blog post linked above will apply to any finite system if you assume exponential growth in power use, and exponential beats cubic for expansion to other worlds (I’m assuming no FTL for a cubic limit to expansion).
Abundant power — be it from fusion or solar or quantum magic — does not actually need to guarantee eternal exponential growth of power use, but the absence of such growth would necessarily lead eventually to the absence of economic growth.
We can still have a SciFi future without that, it will just look different in a way our current society can’t properly envision (which I think is an unsurprising a claim to make even in the absence of the rest of this argument).