News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Onivim 2 – A retro-futuristic modal editor by mintplant on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @04:13AM (#28454467)
It's not Electron, it's their own native UI framework, Revery. This is mentioned up front on the linked site.
Re:Onivim 2 – A retro-futuristic modal editor by Aaargh20318 on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @04:46AM (#28454669)
From the linked Revery UI framework they use:

> if your app looks or behaves differently on another platform, that's a bug! As a consequence, Revery is like flutter in that it does not use native widgets.

No native widgets is a hard pass. One of the biggest advantages of native code is using native widgets, that look, feel and function as all other widgets om that platform. Doing native code but rolling your own widgets is missing the point completely.

Apps should look and behave differently on different platforms, they should look and behave like native apps for that platform. Why would I care if an app looks the same on Windows, macOS and Linux when I'm not using all those OSes at the same time ? This feels like a benefit for the developer, not the end-user.

Re:Onivim 2 – A retro-futuristic modal editor by doix on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @09:22AM (#28456591)
> Why would I care if an app looks the same on Windows, macOS and Linux when I'm not using all those OSes at the same time ?

Sometimes you do switch, and having everything be the same in your editor is nice. I normally work in linux on a desktop and have a windows machine due to corporate policy. Because of COVID, I started working from home on my laptop and VNC'ed into my linux machine to do work. It worked fine until my ISP decided to be shit, so out of frustration I just switched to developing on windows. Since I was using IntelliJ, I just exported my settings from Linux, imported to windows and everything just worked and looked the same.

In theory, I kind of agree with you. But in practice, having a consistent experience across all OS'es is nice. The ship has sailed anyway, nothing looks consistent across different applications on the same platform anyway. Might as well have applications be consistent across different platforms instead.

Re:Onivim 2 – A retro-futuristic modal editor by itsme-alan on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @04:52AM (#28454697)
Unfortunately no one gives a shit about native UI. Look at apps like Spotify and other Electron apps
Re:Onivim 2 – A retro-futuristic modal editor by Aaargh20318 on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @05:30AM (#28454913)
Developers don't give a shit (or more likely: their managers who want to save a buck) user do but have little choice.