I'd guess a savings account at least fails the "common enterprise" part of the test.
From the linked PDF:
> Lower courts have disagreed about the proper test for assessing the “common enterprise” element of the Howey test, and have adopted three basic approaches to this requirement: (1) “horizontal commonality,” (2) “broad vertical commonality,” and (3) “narrow vertical commonality.”105 Under the horizontal commonality approach, a “common enterprise” exists where investors pool assets and “share in the profits and risks of the enterprise.”106 By contrast, vertical commonality emphasizes the relationship between an investor and the promoter of an enterprise. Under the broad vertical commonality approach, a “common enterprise” exists where an investor’s fortunes are dependent on the efforts or expertise of the promoter or his agents.107 Under the narrow vertical commonality approach, a “common enterprise” exists where an investor’s fortunes are dependent not only on a promoter’s efforts or expertise, but also on a promoter’s profits.108
Is usdc money?
"an investment of money" in the Howey test is not about literal money, it can be anything with monetary value, e.g. orange groves.
https://www.finra.org/filing-reporting/regulatory-filing-sys....
FINRA is entirely subservient to the SEC.
You’re thinking of something else. FINRA is a non-profit self-regulating organisation. It has no power over anyone who doesn’t voluntarily submit to its rules. It is not a part of the government.
The SEC was created by the Securities Exchange Act of 1934. It regulates FINRA [1].
The regulator the SEC has constant turf battles with is the CFTC [2].
[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Financial_Industry_Regulator...
[2] https://www.cftc.gov/sites/default/files/idc/groups/public/@...
Financial industry participants are required by the SEC to submit to its rules and regulatory authority. You literally cannot create a financial institution without being forced to submit to FINRA.
Yes, you can. To trade securities you have to be a member of an SRO, of which FINRA is one and the largest. (MSRB is another. Before 2007 there were non-NASD NYSE members. And if you're starting a bank or a hedge fund or a VC firm, FINRA has nothing to do with you.)
Going back to the original assertion: yes, FINRA was created by and is subservient to the SEC. If FINRA has proper jurisdiction, the SEC certainly does.
Coinbase's Lend product pools USDC from customers, and lends them out to ??? who does ??? and pays Coinbase interest for it. Presumably the ???'s are "crypto traders" and "trades crypto, possibly with leverage", respectively. Those specific details dont matter, though.
According to the SEC: "To determine whether a transaction involves an offering of 'securities,' courts employ a four-part test outlined by the Supreme Court’s 1946 decision in SEC v. W.J. Howey Co. Under that test, a transaction qualifies as an offering of 'securities' if it involves:
(1) an investment of money,
(2) in a common enterprise,
(3) with a reasonable expectation of profit,
(4) to be derived from the efforts of others" [0]
I'm not a lawyer or a securities regulator, but it seems hard to see why Coinbase Lend doesn't qualify as a security under those rules.
[0] https://sgp.fas.org/crs/misc/R45301.pdf (coincidentially this PDF is about ICOs, but isnt directly related to the current SEC action against Coinbase).