News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:WhatsApp moderators can read your messages if someone you... by jaywalk on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @04:01PM (#28449168)
No, that's not what the article is saying. There are two ends, but if one of the ends decides to forward the content to WhatsApp, then WhatsApp can read it. Which isn't shocking or breaking E2EE in any way.
Re:WhatsApp moderators can read your messages if someone you... by sigjuice on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @04:13PM (#28449295)
How does one confirm how many “ends” are there in a conversation? If WhatsApp secretly set themselves (or another third party) up as an “end” in every conversation , that would also not break break E2EE.
Re:WhatsApp moderators can read your messages if someone you... by roywiggins on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @04:20PM (#28449387)
Sure, but that's not what's being reported here.
Re:WhatsApp moderators can read your messages if someone you... by sigjuice on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @04:46PM (#28449734)
My comment was not about the original article. It was directed at the comment above me which stated "There are two ends ...".
Re:WhatsApp moderators can read your messages if someone you... by jaywalk on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @04:55PM (#28449832)
Well my comment was about the original article being misrepresented by the comment I replied to, so your comment adds nothing to that conversation.
Re:WhatsApp moderators can read your messages if someone you... by sigjuice on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @05:45PM (#28450343)
My comment still stands on its own. How do you know there are only "two ends"?
Re:WhatsApp moderators can read your messages if someone you... by Uberphallus on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @04:36AM (#28454591)
> There are two ends, but if one of the ends decides to forward the content to WhatsApp, then WhatsApp can read it.

Translation: there are two ends, but one of the ends can send it to yet another end. That sounds like there are more than two ends.

Re:WhatsApp moderators can read your messages if someone you... by Shish2k on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @05:18AM (#28454834)
Ok, but if we use this definition, then “somebody took a screenshot of my Signal chat and posted it on Twitter” is proof that “Twitter can read your Signal messages”. That doesn’t seem like a very practical definition.
Re:WhatsApp moderators can read your messages if someone you... by Uberphallus on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @09:33AM (#28456706)
A screenshot can be forged, meanwhile Facebook has reasonable certainty about the authenticity of the message. This third end is within the WhatsApp platform, so we're not really comparing the same thing.

It's essentially a forward to the party that supposedly can't see your messages, breaking what people understand by E2E.

Today this behavior is triggered when it's reported, tomorrow it'll be when the government, or worse, some AI, flags a user. You share a groupchat with the wrong person, or they have you in their contact list, boom, eavesdropped.

But some people will still claim it's only 2 ends just because it's not forwarded 100% of the time. I guess it's matter of semantics.