Re:Who Rules America: An Investment Manager's View on the To...
by webXL on Thursday August 04, 2011 @01:57AM
(#2844828)
Right, new dollars have to enter the economy somewhere, and the purchasing power is increased at those points of entry, decreased everywhere else by an proportional amount.
I'm all for bitcoin but the powers at be will find a way to stop it if it catches on. But the cat is out of the bag. I just can't see the dollar standing up to all the benefits a technology like bitcoin affords.
Re:Who Rules America: An Investment Manager's View on the To...
by jules on Thursday August 04, 2011 @05:20AM
(#2845224)
What he's saying is that new dollars don't have to enter the economy. If you remove one penny and inject 100 penny pennies, you've only split up the penny, nothing else. With electronic banking this doesn't even have to be anything, as you can just work with fractional dollars (yes I know current software doesn't work like that, but it could).
Re:Who Rules America: An Investment Manager's View on the To...
by webXL on Thursday August 04, 2011 @12:09PM
(#2846547)
And I agree with that as well. There might be some psychological issues switching to a deflationary system, though. Things that typically appreciate in nominal value (real estate, job skills, precious metals, art, etc.) will be appear to not be appreciating, even though relative to everyday goods in services, they will still appreciate. The only problem is that you can't have too much deflation, or else people will want to hold onto cash too much, will they not?
As for replacing the dollar, bitcoin is the only reasonable alternative that presently exists. Fiat currencies almost certainly will never work, because the temptation to inflate them is too great. Gold can't work because you can't send it over the internet. But bitcoins both can't be inflated and can be sent over the internet. No government will decide to switch from dollars/Euros/whatever to bitcoins. Rather, it will be the market that chooses them if they are appropriate.
[1] If you actually halted inflation of the dollar, then as technology continues to increase the supply of everything, eventually the dollar would be so valuable that a cup of coffee would cost less than a penny. You would need to make new monetary units worth less than a penny so that cheap things like coffee can be purchased with them. You would do this by taking your pennies to a bank and getting, say, 100 penny pennies with each penny, and then a cup of coffee could cost 78 penny pennies.