News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Jeff Bezos and the New Pharoahs by civilized on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @01:04AM (#28441117)
I'm sure this guy could have written a whiny, scornful article at any stage of mankind's progress.

"Earth rotates around the Sun? Who is this Galileo, a Sun-worshipper??"

Lucky for him, in this timeline he survives to adulthood to write his Substack blog, rather than dying of polio, smallpox and/or the plague. He lives beyond the wildest dreams of a pharaoh and takes it utterly for granted.

New Pharaohs indeed.

Re:Jeff Bezos and the New Pharoahs by Barrin92 on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @01:47AM (#28441339)
But immortality for the individual is not progress for mankind but the opposite. Stagnation.

Death is an evolutionary mechanism, it's a fundamental part of renewal of the species. Biological life dies to introduce novelty, in a cultural sense it is what gives urgency to human action, creating new life. Human immortality is the same thing as the suppression of forest fire. Fires are bad for some individuals but they're vital for the ecosystem. It's the natural version of creative destruction. If you dislike the idea of an immortal company or an immortal government you should be wary of the idea of immortal individuals. One of the longest lived species on earth is the sponge. It is no accident that they're not a very dynamic species.

Good ideas always survive, Galileo's contribution to mankind exists without Galileo, but as scientists often point out, science advances one funeral at a time. And that can be taken quite literally.

Re:Jeff Bezos and the New Pharoahs by madrox on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @06:42PM (#28450780)
I have a hard time with these arguments...mainly because if we already lived in a world with immortality, and someone came along talking about all the great benefits to society that would happen if we instituted a global end of life program, no one would take them up on it. Consider that while thinking "good ideas always survive."
Re:Jeff Bezos and the New Pharoahs by Xplune13 on Thursday September 09, 2021 @01:30AM (#28466588)
But we don't, do we? We wouldn't even know if we would have anything like today's world. So basing the possible scenario based on a hypothetical situation won't lead us anywhere. It is the same like "If I was the emperor of the world from the start, I would do this and this". My point is, how would you know what you would do when you haven't experienced it yourself? You're basing what you would do on your model of the world which was formed this way (present way) and not the "already emperor" way. So, you wouldn't know anything about how things would be in that hypothetical scenario.

I don't know what category I fall into right now, but I do understand that there might be potentially huge (bad) changes because of this that can stagnate the whole species rather than pushing forward. These possible scenarios are based on the real world, so they must be taken into account.

Re:Jeff Bezos and the New Pharoahs by madrox on Thursday September 09, 2021 @02:40AM (#28466971)
If you're saying the point is moot because it's hypothetical, I don't find that terribly convincing. We conduct thought experiments all the time.

If you're saying immortality shouldn't be allowed because it could lead to negative change, well...feel free to opt out should the option arrive. To paraphrase Cory Doctorow, no one need convince you...simply outlive you.

However, I don't think you would. I think you'd opt in and deal with the consequences later, since at least you'll be alive to experience them. We accept change all the time without considering consequences if the individual gain is strong enough.

Re:Jeff Bezos and the New Pharoahs by Xplune13 on Friday September 17, 2021 @12:46AM (#28561319)
Sorry for the late reply, but those thought experiments are exactly that... a thought experiment, most of them never come anywhere close to reality.

I'm not saying it shouldn't be allowed, but that is a huge leap in one's understanding of the world. The possible effects of leap should be thoroughly studied before making those leaps, because it can backfire due to unseen consequences. Blindly following immortality as a way to live isn't a right way in my opinion.

> We accept change all the time without considering consequences if the individual gain is strong enough. Not all changes are equal and arguably immortality would be the biggest change humanity has ever faced, so I don't think this is a matter of "We'll see things afterwards", but of "let's first study the possible good and bad consequences of that and then decide if we want to do this or not". Advancement for the sake of advancement isn't a right way to go in my opinion, especially not when majority of changes will now affect ALL the people on Earth as we're all connected now.

On the topic of, will I opt in? It depends on the consequences. I would prefer not to be a tester of such thing, so I won't opt in if I'm in the trial batch or even first public batch. Feel free to do so if you want to, but try not to say "what you think others will do" based on an internet comment because that again is based on the mental model you have right now which is a narrow slice (same for everyone). Now, would I like to live a good life (90-100 years)? Yeah sure, but I really don't feel like I want to live beyond that. I might want to extend that life if I find some purpose later in life, but even after that I don't think I'll ever want to live forever.

Re:Jeff Bezos and the New Pharoahs by madrox on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @01:09AM (#28441146)
The author's bio reads "A fellow primate who wonders why we ever came down from the trees."

I get the impression he unironically is asking that like a Douglas Adams character.

"Many were increasingly of the opinion that they'd all made a big mistake coming down from the trees in the first place, and some said that even the trees had been a bad move, and that no-one should ever have left the oceans."

Re:Jeff Bezos and the New Pharoahs by starkd on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @12:56PM (#28447027)
I think he wrote that entirely in jest. His larger point is about the folly of mankind's idea about progress. Technology, however invigorating and useful, can easily become another false idol.
Re:Jeff Bezos and the New Pharoahs by madrox on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @06:36PM (#28450735)
I have a hard time believing that assertion given how this article was written. It's full of ad hominem attacks and naturalistic fallacies. This is not mere punditry.
Re:Jeff Bezos and the New Pharoahs by civilized on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @01:13AM (#28441167)
He should take a plane to the Congo and give it a try. Maybe a sympathetic pack of chimps will take him in.
Re:Jeff Bezos and the New Pharoahs by overflowing on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @01:21AM (#28441201)
Critiquing the ideologies of the wealthy and powerful is not the same thing as rejecting the benefits of healthcare.

Bezo's achievements are not "mankind's" achievements

Re:Jeff Bezos and the New Pharoahs by irjustin on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @01:28AM (#28441239)
> Bezo's achievements are not "mankind's" achievements

Why not? If we made it to Mars on Musk's ship... I'd be happy to declare it both his and our win.

Re:Jeff Bezos and the New Pharoahs by courtf on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @01:38AM (#28441291)
Comparing Bezos to Galileo, what a joke.

Back then an equivalent article would have targeted the church, and its author probably would have suffered greatly for doing so, sort of like our friend Galileo... Your obsequiousness, especially pathetic in this age when the stakes are so much lower, would have spared you from facing any similar repercussions I'm sure.

Re:Jeff Bezos and the New Pharoahs by civilized on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @11:49AM (#28446217)
Grand rhetoric! But no one is facing any repercussions for their opinion either way, and neither opinion is considered especially virtuous. I'm just saying what I think. So you can spare us the grandstanding.
Re:Jeff Bezos and the New Pharoahs by anonuser123456 on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @01:33AM (#28441258)
> Lucky for him

But unlucky for us.