News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Very Weird Solicitation Alert by neilv on Monday September 06, 2021 @10:32PM (#28440232)
> *Using one of my burner names and emails, I signed the NDA,

Any lawyer want to comment on that?

Re:Very Weird Solicitation Alert by blamazon on Monday September 06, 2021 @11:04PM (#28440469)
I’m not a lawyer, but generally when dealing with contracts, the actual “signature” that’s on the “paper” is somewhat inconsequential. Sure, it’s convenient for record keeping, and easy to defend in a court of law, but it’s not the be-all, end-all of consent to a contract.

If you make a good faith effort to convey to a contract participant what is at stake in the contract, (perhaps by writing it out in the form of an NDA) and the intended participant does something to imply consent, like splashing ink on the paper in the spot where it says “by putting ink on this spot I agree to the terms”, or clicking an equivalent button, the participant can be held to the terms regardless of what shape the ink or the pixels make.

In terms of defending your contract in court, this can be another matter entirely. If you don’t have some proof that the participant did actually acknowledge the terms of the contract and consent to the terms willfully, you will find it difficult to enforce the contract.

Depending on the method used for “signing” the NDA, using a burner alias likely has little to no legal difference from actually signing with real name and subsequently flaunting the NDA in the same manner.

However, in terms of getting away with it, the burner alias might be enough to throw off the opponent. No point accusing an anonymous stranger of breach of contract… they need to be deanonymized first to affect damages.

If you can’t deanonymize me, you can’t affect damages to me, regardless of what I sign.

Re:Very Weird Solicitation Alert by shp0ngle on Monday September 06, 2021 @11:23PM (#28440593)
The author of this blogpost is, however, not anonymous, so de-anonymizing is fairly easy, no?
Re:Very Weird Solicitation Alert by onionisafruit on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @12:48AM (#28441033)
Is somebody claiming to have signed a contract on a blog post significant evidence that they actually signed it? Can you say “one of these 1000 signatures is probably his pseudonym but I don’t know which one” and have it stand up in court?

Of course it falls apart if the author is compelled to answer in court whether they signed. Then it comes down to whether they are willing to debase themselves by lying.

Re:Very Weird Solicitation Alert by SideburnsOfDoom on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @04:07AM (#28442244)
The author of this blog post is probably prepared to risk it, on the assumption that the people that they are writing about really don't want to be in court testifying under oath on this matter.
Re:Very Weird Solicitation Alert by Talanes on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @12:53AM (#28441054)
She said her writing sample was a snippet pasted from one of her novels, so the information to de-anonymize her is there.
Re:Very Weird Solicitation Alert by onionisafruit on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @01:23AM (#28441218)
I didn’t think about that part (apparently my reading comprehension is bad enough that I also used the wrong pronoun for the author). Assuming Main actually saved the writing samples and does the work to match them all against the author’s novels, then she should be able to pin it down. It will be interesting if we get to see what damages she sues for.

If she is willing to lie she could still say somebody else signed the nda and forwarded her the information to post. I wouldn’t do that personally, but I also wouldn’t think unkindly of somebody who did.

Re:Very Weird Solicitation Alert by blamazon on Monday September 06, 2021 @11:26PM (#28440605)
Seems like it. So, in this case in a legal sense, I believe there to be basically no difference to signing with an alias vs signing with real name, particularly since they blogged about doing this.
Re:Very Weird Solicitation Alert by kadoban on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @12:22AM (#28440903)
Would some kind of clean hands argument potentially stop this NDA from being enforceable though?
Re:Very Weird Solicitation Alert by celticninja on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @05:26AM (#28442718)
Not if they cannot connect the poster with a NDA signed by an alias.
Re:Very Weird Solicitation Alert by mountainb on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @09:00AM (#28444190)
Contract is by and large a state law issue and many states have statutes that look askance at format deficiencies and expect signatures to be formatted in certain ways. The judge also has to be able to understand the contract as written to rule on it, so a contract of a smudge would be hard to enforce.

Signing a false name on a contract is fraud. It is different. They would have trouble doing anything if they could not serve you because they didn't know who you were. But if you used an online service to sign the contract, they could serve the company who facilitated it demanding they reveal your identity and doxx you that way.

Re:Very Weird Solicitation Alert by wly_cdgr on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @05:36AM (#28442771)
Y'all are taking this way too seriously. This Monica Main person isn't suing anyone for NDA breach when she knows damn well her whole scheme's a fraud
Re:Very Weird Solicitation Alert by dsr_ on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @09:00AM (#28444192)
The trend among frauds and con artists is to double down when caught; it's entirely possible that Monica Main will sue and then use the unresolved court case as pseudoevidence that her enterprise is being attacked by shills of a conspiracy.
Re:Very Weird Solicitation Alert by babyblueblanket on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @10:43AM (#28445474)
Author Beware however has an extremely long track record of calling out fraudsters. Any author who reads a warning from them would do well to take them over the word of any fraudster.
Re:Very Weird Solicitation Alert by blamazon on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @09:46AM (#28444764)
Zoom out a little--hackers tend to be beholden to NDAs and so the legal mechanisms are of interest.