News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fallacies I have encountered when disccusing 100% renewab... by tasty_freeze on Monday September 06, 2021 @12:25PM (#28435287)
One thing I hear frequently against wind energy is "but what about the birds?" Usually this is said by someone who politically doesn't care about wildlife.

1. effort is put into abating the issue to some degree.

2. billions of birds are killed due to human activity. Number one is house cats, but impacts with windows and cars is orders of magnitude more than due to wind turbines.

3. wind power displaces gas and coal power. the effects of pollution (particulates, mercury, etc) is far worse than wind turbines for birds. not only that but it is better for anything that breathes oxygen, including humans.

So if the "what about the birds" crowd actually cared about birds, they'd push for wind power over coal. But it isn't about the birds; it is a pretext for keeping the status quo.

Re:Fallacies I have encountered when disccusing 100% renewab... by gcheong on Monday September 06, 2021 @12:46PM (#28435530)
The kind of bird is important. Many more songbirds are taken by cats it’s true but their numbers aren’t in danger. Wind turbines impact mainly larger birds such as raptors that don’t reproduce as quickly. The problem is such that a wind farm might be allowed a single kill before fines or being shut down and some places are trying to develop early warning systems to shut down a turbine if a bird is detected. Seems a long way around to go just for a single type of renewable when you could most likely solve most problems with nuclear.
Re:Fallacies I have encountered when disccusing 100% renewab... by stewbrew on Monday September 06, 2021 @02:01PM (#28436313)
Wild life would totally benefit from nuclear power. This is often overlooked by environmentalists. Look at Tschernobyl. It's like hitting the reset button and removing humans (a bug, not a feature) from the equation.
Re:Fallacies I have encountered when disccusing 100% renewab... by gcheong on Monday September 06, 2021 @02:59PM (#28436814)
If only such disasters weren’t rare to begin with and completely preventable with modern designs!
Re:Fallacies I have encountered when disccusing 100% renewab... by stewbrew on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @04:04AM (#28442221)
That's what they said 1985.
Re:Fallacies I have encountered when disccusing 100% renewab... by nine_k on Monday September 06, 2021 @02:01PM (#28436318)
Nuclear has two problems: high cost due to lack of scale, and bad publicity. The crazy people which produced the Chernobyl disaster not only directly killed hundreds of people and displaced hundreds of thousands, they turned the whole idea of nuclear power generation into a hobgoblin.

The "nuclear waste" is still mostly fuel, it can be processed and burned further. But this involves, among other things, producing and extracting plutonium (which itself is a fine nuclear fuel), and thus some suspicion of producing more nuclear weapons.

Re:Fallacies I have encountered when disccusing 100% renewab... by nmz on Monday September 06, 2021 @02:36PM (#28436628)
Re:Fallacies I have encountered when disccusing 100% renewab... by andromeduck on Monday September 06, 2021 @12:36PM (#28435407)
Wind only displaces gas and coal when governments aren't shutting down nuclear to persue it like in Germany, California, New York, etc.
Re:Fallacies I have encountered when disccusing 100% renewab... by pfdietz on Monday September 06, 2021 @01:16PM (#28435853)
Re:Fallacies I have encountered when disccusing 100% renewab... by andromeduck on Monday September 06, 2021 @01:38PM (#28436068)
Re:Fallacies I have encountered when disccusing 100% renewab... by pfdietz on Monday September 06, 2021 @01:43PM (#28436117)
That paper is comparing what happened to what would have happened without the nuclear phase out. That is, coal would have gone down MORE if nuclear had not been phased out. It does not support your claim that nuclear was replaced by coal. As the graph I gave you shows, coal use there declined over this decade, even as nuclear has also declined.
Re:Fallacies I have encountered when disccusing 100% renewab... by LaMarseillaise on Monday September 06, 2021 @02:38PM (#28436638)
It is absolutely true:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Encina_Power_Station#Retiremen...

I lived there. I believed the 'environmentalists' when they said that SONGS would be replaced by renewables. I am not falling for it again.

Re:Fallacies I have encountered when disccusing 100% renewab... by pfdietz on Monday September 06, 2021 @02:45PM (#28436702)
He made a universal statement. You presenting an example where it might be true doesn't save his statement, when I can present an example where it is wrong.
Re:Fallacies I have encountered when disccusing 100% renewab... by LaMarseillaise on Monday September 06, 2021 @03:15PM (#28436955)
Universal statement? The above commenter specified California. I provided an example confirming that statement for California.

Not to mention, the comment is practically a truism aside from the locations mentioned:

"Wind only displaces gas and coal when governments aren't shutting down nuclear to persue [sic] it..."

If a nuclear plant were shut down and replaced entirely with wind, then that necessarily means that coal and gas are not displaced.

Re:Fallacies I have encountered when disccusing 100% renewab... by pfdietz on Monday September 06, 2021 @03:27PM (#28437056)
I see you edited out the part that shows you are wrong.

"Wind only displaces gas and coal when governments aren't shutting down nuclear to persue it like in Germany, California, New York, etc."

Notice that word "Germany"?

Re:Fallacies I have encountered when disccusing 100% renewab... by rufus_foreman on Monday September 06, 2021 @03:40PM (#28437182)
>> Usually this is said by someone who

That's a logical fallacy. You already lost me.

Re:Fallacies I have encountered when disccusing 100% renewab... by rufus_foreman on Monday September 06, 2021 @02:51PM (#28436752)
>> Usually this is said by someone who politically doesn't care about wildlife

Whether someone cares about wildlife does not affect whether a logical argument is true or not.

Re:Fallacies I have encountered when disccusing 100% renewab... by Gibbon1 on Monday September 06, 2021 @03:15PM (#28436950)
It's a good indication of manipulative and bad faith arguments.
Re:Fallacies I have encountered when disccusing 100% renewab... by rufus_foreman on Monday September 06, 2021 @03:55PM (#28437343)
Bad faith arguments are just logically valid arguments with which you happen to disagree.
Re:Fallacies I have encountered when disccusing 100% renewab... by Gibbon1 on Monday September 06, 2021 @04:33PM (#28437751)
You should not conflate someone arguing in bad faith with someone is arguing in good faith. Their whole agenda is to distract you from the problem you are trying to solve.
Re:Fallacies I have encountered when disccusing 100% renewab... by rufus_foreman on Monday September 06, 2021 @04:36PM (#28437796)
There is no problem that I am trying to solve. Maybe that's your thing?
Re:Fallacies I have encountered when disccusing 100% renewab... by 2OEH8eoCRo0 on Monday September 06, 2021 @02:18PM (#28436456)
Why do these fossil fuels billionaires seem like such morons? They have so much money they could invest in renewables and then "own" the next couple of hundred years of energy at least. Instead, they use money to fight against inevitable change.

Am I missing something?

Re:Fallacies I have encountered when disccusing 100% renewab... by jmnicolas on Monday September 06, 2021 @02:35PM (#28436618)
Because fossil fuels are much more convenient, reliable and efficient. If there is no wind and or no sun you have no power, so now you have to invest in expensive batteries to bridge meteorologic conditions.

Compare an EV and a petrol one. If you want to go from Lisbon to Vladivostok, this will be a breeze with a petrol car and a headache with an EV (I'm not sure it's even possible, good luck charging it fast in the deepest parts of Russia).

Re:Fallacies I have encountered when disccusing 100% renewab... by 2OEH8eoCRo0 on Monday September 06, 2021 @05:38PM (#28438397)
I'm not saying to end all fossil fuels, we obviously need them, but you can use your profits to fund the next sources of energy rather than fight change.

Fusion and nuclear count too imo. Those work rain or shine.

Re:Fallacies I have encountered when disccusing 100% renewab... by angelzen on Monday September 06, 2021 @02:05PM (#28436353)
This is sadly a general trend. Take some numbers out of context. The numbers appear large because they are a small fraction of really really large population. Publish on social media and induce outrage. Clicks and clout follow. For example: covid deaths, which are 1-3% of total deaths from all causes for young people and up to 10-15% for older generations.

https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/nvss/vsrr/covid_weekly/index.htm

Re:Fallacies I have encountered when disccusing 100% renewab... by tejohnso on Monday September 06, 2021 @01:15PM (#28435850)
Another thing I heard about wind energy recently was that the friction of the blades significantly warms the air, so if deployed at scale, the total effect on atmospheric warming would not be as beneficial as hoped.

Not sure how valid it is, but I thought it was interesting and hadn't heard it before.

Re:Fallacies I have encountered when disccusing 100% renewab... by colechristensen on Monday September 06, 2021 @01:26PM (#28435951)
That is not even remotely valid, the easiest way to think about it is through energy conservation: the atmosphere would have to be significantly heating itself from energy it already had.
Re:Fallacies I have encountered when disccusing 100% renewab... by tzs on Monday September 06, 2021 @04:20PM (#28437612)
Does all the energy to run a wind turbine come from the energy produced by that turbine's blades?

I'd expect several components of a wind turbine to require power. Its electronic components may need power for cooling or heating depending on the season. The motors that change the blade pitch need power.

Some of these things need to work when the blades are stopped. One way to do that would be to power them from the grid instead of from the turbine.

If those things are grid powered, then a wind turbine might actually very very very slightly raise local atmospheric temperature.

Anyone here happen to know if they actually do power anything in the turbine from the grid, or if they do something else like power such things from batteries that get recharged by the turbine when it is generating power?

Re:Fallacies I have encountered when disccusing 100% renewab... by 63 on Monday September 06, 2021 @01:21PM (#28435896)
I'm by no means an expert here, but wouldn't the energy that is expressed as heat in that friction just be the energy that's already in the air? Wouldn't it just be expressed as heat and friction anyway as air moves past other objects and other air? It doesn't make sense that turbines would be putting more energy into the system than they're taking out.
Re:Fallacies I have encountered when disccusing 100% renewab... by Arnavion on Monday September 06, 2021 @02:21PM (#28436471)
In an ideal frictionless encounter between air particle and turbine blade, the particle loses some kinetic energy and the blade gains the same kinetic energy.

In a real encounter with friction, some of the KE is lost to heat.

The initial source of the particle's KE was heat from the Sun causing weather. So the net energy is constant, the local temperature is higher because the blade has heated up at the cost of the air particle's motion, but overall temperature is the same because more heat from the sun will be needed to restore the air particle's motion that was lost to friction. It all balances out in the end.

The fact that the total energy is the same doesn't necessarily mean it's okay. Hypothetically if wind turbines set up a gradient so that the first few meters of atmosphere become hotter and the rest of the atmosphere becomes colder, total energy is conserved, but it's not a desirable outcome. But I don't know if humans can build enough wind turbines to make that possible; the Earth is very big and the atmosphere has a lot of mass.

Re:Fallacies I have encountered when disccusing 100% renewab... by kergonath on Monday September 06, 2021 @01:34PM (#28436028)
That would be another kind of perpetual motion/unlimited energy production device.
Re:Fallacies I have encountered when disccusing 100% renewab... by kergonath on Monday September 06, 2021 @01:32PM (#28435997)
That's bullshit. They can plausibly cause some surprising changes by disturbing the local air circulation patterns (which can either increase or decrease temperatures at a very local level), but increasing the temperature because of friction is a fantasy.

If this were happening at a significant scale, it would decrease atmospheric temperatures, because the energy that ends up heating the blades would have to come from somewhere, and the air would lose some of its kinetic energy.