The "nuclear waste" is still mostly fuel, it can be processed and burned further. But this involves, among other things, producing and extracting plutonium (which itself is a fine nuclear fuel), and thus some suspicion of producing more nuclear weapons.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_and_radiation_accident...
https://www.cleanenergywire.org/sites/default/files/styles/g...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Encina_Power_Station#Retiremen...
I lived there. I believed the 'environmentalists' when they said that SONGS would be replaced by renewables. I am not falling for it again.
Not to mention, the comment is practically a truism aside from the locations mentioned:
"Wind only displaces gas and coal when governments aren't shutting down nuclear to persue [sic] it..."
If a nuclear plant were shut down and replaced entirely with wind, then that necessarily means that coal and gas are not displaced.
"Wind only displaces gas and coal when governments aren't shutting down nuclear to persue it like in Germany, California, New York, etc."
Notice that word "Germany"?
That's a logical fallacy. You already lost me.
Whether someone cares about wildlife does not affect whether a logical argument is true or not.
Am I missing something?
Compare an EV and a petrol one. If you want to go from Lisbon to Vladivostok, this will be a breeze with a petrol car and a headache with an EV (I'm not sure it's even possible, good luck charging it fast in the deepest parts of Russia).
Fusion and nuclear count too imo. Those work rain or shine.
Not sure how valid it is, but I thought it was interesting and hadn't heard it before.
I'd expect several components of a wind turbine to require power. Its electronic components may need power for cooling or heating depending on the season. The motors that change the blade pitch need power.
Some of these things need to work when the blades are stopped. One way to do that would be to power them from the grid instead of from the turbine.
If those things are grid powered, then a wind turbine might actually very very very slightly raise local atmospheric temperature.
Anyone here happen to know if they actually do power anything in the turbine from the grid, or if they do something else like power such things from batteries that get recharged by the turbine when it is generating power?
In a real encounter with friction, some of the KE is lost to heat.
The initial source of the particle's KE was heat from the Sun causing weather. So the net energy is constant, the local temperature is higher because the blade has heated up at the cost of the air particle's motion, but overall temperature is the same because more heat from the sun will be needed to restore the air particle's motion that was lost to friction. It all balances out in the end.
The fact that the total energy is the same doesn't necessarily mean it's okay. Hypothetically if wind turbines set up a gradient so that the first few meters of atmosphere become hotter and the rest of the atmosphere becomes colder, total energy is conserved, but it's not a desirable outcome. But I don't know if humans can build enough wind turbines to make that possible; the Earth is very big and the atmosphere has a lot of mass.
If this were happening at a significant scale, it would decrease atmospheric temperatures, because the energy that ends up heating the blades would have to come from somewhere, and the air would lose some of its kinetic energy.
1. effort is put into abating the issue to some degree.
2. billions of birds are killed due to human activity. Number one is house cats, but impacts with windows and cars is orders of magnitude more than due to wind turbines.
3. wind power displaces gas and coal power. the effects of pollution (particulates, mercury, etc) is far worse than wind turbines for birds. not only that but it is better for anything that breathes oxygen, including humans.
So if the "what about the birds" crowd actually cared about birds, they'd push for wind power over coal. But it isn't about the birds; it is a pretext for keeping the status quo.