News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:When patents attack Android by davidu on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @04:58PM (#2843065)
I'm not pro-patent, I just want Google's motives as I see them to be more transparent, and that is what I am aiming to achieve with my comment.

If they thought patents were more strategic for them, they wouldn't be anti-patent. For them it's purely a strategic viewpoint that benefits them due to their current size.

That patents are grossly abused is a serious issue that is quickly coming to a head, so it won't take ages from now for major reform to occur.

Re:When patents attack Android by moultano on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @05:14PM (#2843133)
So if the ethical position is also strategic, it is no longer ethical? That's a pretty high standard for what constitutes ethical behavior.

>If they thought patents were more strategic for them, they wouldn't be anti-patent.

This needs a gigantic [citation needed] next to it.

Re:When patents attack Android by davidu on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @06:00PM (#2843351)
You believe that being pro IPP or anti IPP is an ethical position?

I am pro IP protection (IPP) and but I strongly dislike the existing IPP system we have.

Re:When patents attack Android by moultano on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @09:04PM (#2844040)
What do you mean? Any normative statement is ultimately an ethical one, so any position on the proper use and law of patents is an ethical position as well.
Re:When patents attack Android by davidu on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @09:13PM (#2844074)
You're conflating two issues. An individual can be in support of protecting intellectual property and against our current laws that implement said protection.
Re:When patents attack Android by moultano on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @09:27PM (#2844108)
I agree. I didn't say otherwise. My assertion is that Google's position is still an ethical one even though it is also strategic.
Re:When patents attack Android by davidu on Thursday August 04, 2011 @12:48AM (#2844616)
It may be your ethical belief that all patents are bad, but we know it isn't Google's. They have hundreds of patents, a number of which list one of your co-founders as inventors.

So sure, I guess it's nice that in this instance your company's strategy lines up with your ethical beliefs.

Re:When patents attack Android by dman on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @05:08PM (#2843114)
Companies that consider themselves in a growth phase take an anti intellectual property stance. Once they are sitting on an empire they shift positions. Its the rational thing to do. All this says about Google is that they are still looking to enter and disrupt new markets.
Re:When patents attack Android by Steko on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @05:21PM (#2843166)
I'd say the dynamic is more complicated, many small businesses are highly reliant on IP protections. Innovators are pro-IP, followers are contra-IP.
Re:When patents attack Android by kelnos on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @05:40PM (#2843265)
Innovators are pro-IP, followers are contra-IP.

Strongly disagree. This kind of statement really needs some supporting evidence.

Re:When patents attack Android by Steko on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @06:21PM (#2843434)
Ok so I'll cite some supporting evidence:

http://infochachkie.com/fast-followers-i/

"Whenever creating an imitation of a successful leader, great care must be taken to avoid outright intellectual property infringement; the closer the duplication, the greater the care which must be exercised. MGA Entertainment (MGA), which produced the Bratz dolls, learned this the hard way. Late in 2008, U.S. Courts forced MGA to cease and desist in the manufacture of the dolls. A jury deemed that the creator of Bratz, Carter Bryant, devised the idea while he was an employee at Mattel. In the Spring of 2009, a U.S. Court of Appeals upheld the jury decision, mandating that the intellectual property associated with Bratz dolls was the sole property of Mattel."

Re:When patents attack Android by kelnos on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @07:05PM (#2843608)
Making a blanket statement about all innovators and all followers is an extraordinary claim, which requires extraordinary evidence. A reference to a single court case between a pair of companies hardly passes that bar.

Regardless, reading your linked article, it seems to have a pretty positive (or at least neutral) view of being a so-called "follower". It's interesting to point out the NKOTB-follower groups like Backstreet Boys and 'NSync. Regardless of whether or not you like their music, it's hard to deny that they were hugely successful and helped push the "boyband" genre of music into greater popularity. Not saying this is good or bad from an aesthetic point of view, but it sounds good from a business perspective.

Re:When patents attack Android by Steko on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @07:38PM (#2843731)
It seems fairly intuitive to me that innovations are protected by IP so innovators are always for stronger IP protections and wheras followers are always trying to skirt close to the line of infringement without passing it, and thus are disposed towards weaker penalties towards infringement.

I'm surprised at the level of disagreement this assertion has provoked. How much evidence do you really want? Are the Chinese vendors hawking illegal Harry Potter books for or against greater penalties in China for violating IP? Are the fake Apple stores and fake iPhone "KIRF" makers for or against greater IP penalties?

I mean I guess this classification loses value when you start talking about companies like Zynga that both steal and are stolen from (today's injunction). And that probably applies to Apple and many other large businesses but it seems to me that most of these companies put up a fight but ultimately accept that they have to pay for many things -- as Apple did with Amazon's One Click or the IP they buy or the Nokia settlement. OTOH Google seems to have adopted something scarily close to the Chinese pirate model.

Re:When patents attack Android by nitrogen on Friday August 05, 2011 @04:48AM (#2849428)
It seems that you are conflating many separate issues, and using the red herring of Chinese counterfeiters to try to prove something in an unrelated discussion. Long patents, obvious patents, patent trolls, long copyrights, strong copyrights, trademarks, etc. are all invoked in different ways by the examples given here in your and other comments, and a meaningful discussion can be had only when it is clear which aspect of the law is being discussed, and what segments of society the proposed changes will benefit.

Many of the commenters here on Hacker News are innovators in the sense that they are creating new software with new combinations of ideas that have not previously existed. They are also against stronger IP protection, because to date, "stronger IP" has meant ridiculously long copyright terms, broad, non-novel, and painfully obvious patents, etc. Many obvious patents cover things that are essential to the writing of software and have been previously documented by academics, but companies are still using them to demand a tax on the work of true innovators, large and small. A sufficiently-skilled corporate lawyer can paint broad and obtusely-worded patents as covering anything they want in the minds of a lay jury. Patent holders claim to have "invented" things that are considered by programmers as trivial, everyday tasks in their programming. We are not "stealing" their ideas, as we never even hear they exist until a lawsuit comes out of the blue.

I could go on. Such are the landmines facing small, independent and/or open source software creators, and they do nothing but slow down innovation and limit the growth our sector of the economy. Alas, this thread has long since fallen off the front page, so it is probably best left to rest.

Re:When patents attack Android by nitrogen on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @07:14PM (#2843632)
As I understand it[0], Mattel's claim of ownership of the Bratz IP derives from the fact that their creator developed them while subject to an IP assignment and non-compete contract.

The Bratz case seems entirely unrelated to the matter at hand, though in the closest comparison I can see, Mattel is a parasite trying to use IP laws to reap the benefits of creative work done by MGM and the designer of the Bratz dolls. The pro-IP Mattel is not the leader in this case.

[0] Edit: and, according to your article: "A jury deemed that the creator of Bratz, Carter Bryant, devised the idea while he was an employee at Mattel."

Re:When patents attack Android by dman on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @05:26PM (#2843185)
I did not say anything about size of business.

I think a better framing of your latter point would be - incumbents are pro-IP newcomers are contra-IP. Just being first in a field does not mean that you are innovating in it currently.

Re:When patents attack Android by Steko on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @05:37PM (#2843244)
"I did not say anything about size of business."

Well 'empire' has some connotations you may not be aware of.

Re:When patents attack Android by dman on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @06:00PM (#2843352)
Sorry about that, I can now see how I miscommunicated. I was lazily using empire to allude to - 'an economic entity with a well defined identity and well defined borders'.

Let me take an example to clarify this situation - Lets assume a hypothetical situation where Nokia has reached its limits of what it thinks a Phone could be it has stopped doing fundamental innovation ie it has a well defined empire with a well defined cost structure and a well defined revenue model. In such a situation it is in Nokia's self interest to use their immense patent portfolio to create a moat around their business to keep upstarts like Apple / Google away.

On the other hand lets consider another hypothetical situation where Nokia were innovating and trying to reimagine what a phone could be. Perhaps they were doing interesting things in software to displace desktops and make the phone the central location of the users global state. In this case they would be encroaching onto areas where other entities (like Microsoft, Google) might hold significant patents. In this case it would be in Nokia's self interest to be the anti patent candidate.

I have often found that when I use more words to clarify a miscommunication I often end up causing more damage. I hope that is not the case here.