Re:New Evidence Against the Standard Model of Cosmology
by sahil50 on Sunday September 05, 2021 @10:56AM
(#28424791)
Maybe. But my reasoning is to assume as little as possible and start reasoning up from the point in history where the need for an explanation arose.
And the need for an explanation arose when Hubble saw the redshift. He and Zwicky preferred tired light over galactic recession, but the halfwit academic establishment went with galactic recession.
Re:New Evidence Against the Standard Model of Cosmology
by sharpener on Sunday September 05, 2021 @12:53PM
(#28425704)
A fair approach.
Incidentally, I just drew some diagrams and with the assumptions that the Earth is not at the centre of expansion, Earth orbit has extremes (for parallax), and all light only takes straight routes, my second question has a negative answer.
But if one puts a gravitational lens on the view of one of the two stars then (based on a fast doodle though) it looks like maybe expansion could be detected.
Is it possible to have both photon tiring and expansion and still measure the same numbers in experiment?
Also wouldn't the arc separation of deep field stars increase detectably with expansion?