> Goodreads no longer issues new developer keys for our public developer API and plans to retire the current version of these tools.
I generally find that I trust their book ratings more than any other sites, though, seeing as they are user-generated, and also given the amount of users being in the 10s of millions.
BookWyrm seems pretty fantastic and promising from what I see, but I don't know that it would attract the current Goodreads user. I'm really hoping it gets some traction.
[0]: https://help.goodreads.com/s/article/Does-Goodreads-support-...
There are far too many reviews for advanced copies seeded by publishers, though, and there’s no consistent disclosure or way to filter these out.
That, and the rating system is far too simplistic. When you’re optimizing for engagement then having users spend a lot of time reading reviews is probably good. It’s not optimized for time spent to find a good book to read, though.
The ISBN codes seems to be in some weird legal gray area.
The codes can be broken down so you can tell (to some degree) which language, geographic region and publisher was involved and whether the ISBN is valid (as in meets a checksum constraint) and has been "issued" (a continually updating list) managed in a decentralised manner but since it's an older system, it wasn't ever really designed for this kind of usage.
It also hits the problem, that these days you care a little less about the actual physical object, which ISBN was designed around, but certainly a trove of data hidden there.
You're gonna have to move away from western languages entirely to find a book that's not available in one of those.
I started building a GoodReads-equivalent but realized that many people care more about learning from multiple media formats (blogs, videos, research papers, interactive explorables, podcasts, courses etc) rather than simply reading books. Because there are too many projects attempting to build a new GoodReads, I ended up building something more oriented for multimedia learners.
It’s up and running, open-source, built with Ruby on Rails and supports protocols like ActivityPub, RSS etc. There is a companion browser extension, integration with Slack groups, Twitter and more, and a WIP mobile app. Like GoodReads, you can build your learning lists and embed them on your sites.
It participates in fediverse so your reviews can be broadcasted to your followers on Mastodon, PeerTube etc but full federation is not yet there because it has an underlying knowledge graph that will need to be synchronised across instances.
I think many HN users may be interested in checking it out:
https://learnawesome.org/
https://github.com/learn-awesome/learn