News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook Apologizes After A.I. Puts “Primates” Label on V... by suifbwish on Saturday September 04, 2021 @03:19PM (#28418182)
I also happen to be black but that actually has very little bearing on what I have to say and am merely mentioning it to prevent anyone from suggesting that my opinion on the matter is related to my skin color.

The problem with this is no one actually trained the AI to have a racially bias but rather did not train it on recognizing the difference. Why? Probably because no one knew the computer was going to identify this resemblance and immediately label it as such (I have heard babies learning to talk and name shapes/colors do the exact same thing with no outside influence) Computer vision operates on matrices of color coordinates that share resemblances with other similar matrices and attempts to match patterns between multiple sets to establish resemblance. It is not the fault of the computer or the programmer that there are coincidental resemblances that exceed it’s learned threshold where it decides that the two sets represents objects of the same type.

I personally am ok with admitting that my skin color visually is more similar to images of certain non human primates and can understand why this problem is not a programmer bias but actually a complicated computer vision problem as it’s easy to spot the resemblance but often difficult to train a neural net on why the images resemble eachother but are not related.

Re:Facebook Apologizes After A.I. Puts “Primates” Label on V... by jrm4 on Saturday September 04, 2021 @07:30PM (#28420358)
That first sentence, man. Like, I feel bad second guessing people, in some ways it's not my right -- but it so feels like the kind of "respectability" talk I used to say out of what I thought was "the truth," but now realize it was a sort of habitual way to defuse the room.

So I will state clearly -- yes, I am aware my opinions are absolutely related to my skin color and that's precisely why you all need to pay special attention to them. Not because of some sort of silly inherent genetic thing, but because I have experiences that many of you don't.

Re:Facebook Apologizes After A.I. Puts “Primates” Label on V... by pure_simplicity on Sunday September 05, 2021 @10:10PM (#28429571)
> " I am aware my opinions are absolutely related to my skin color and that's precisely why you all need to pay special attention to them. Not because of some sort of silly inherent genetic thing, but because I have experiences that many of you don't."

We used to think of this as racist stereotyping, but in the pendulum of history we have swung back to where in order to not be racist (or, better yet, anti-racist) we have to be actively racist.

The zeitgeist is to view everything through the lens of race / skin color ostensibly in an effort to combat racism, but in reality all it does is create more racism.

The fact that we have multiple black people commenting here with opinions diverging as widely as they do should be proof positive that race or skin color has almost nothing to do with your opinions.

Two people can go through the exact same experience and come out entirely different persons or very similar. Two people can have the same skin color and go through totally different experiences. Two people can have different skin color and go through very similar experiences. Thus when dealing with individuals we should not ascribe to them stereotypes unless we have to make an informed guess, because statistical patterns apply only to groups not individuals.

Guessing my race based on my opinion will be left as an exercise for the unconvinced reader ;)

Re:Facebook Apologizes After A.I. Puts “Primates” Label on V... by jrm4 on Sunday September 05, 2021 @10:40PM (#28429713)
A little exhausting to, as always, have to thread the needle and calm things down, but let's try again.

My insistence on what I said isn't about anything permanent or immutable. This is about what I hope to be a temporary state of affairs, namely that -- it is at least plausible that the lack of black folks in tech today is leading to unintended negative consequences, and perhaps we should talk about that directly without having to worry about the fragile torpedoing the conversation by confusing this hopefully temporary state with some bigger overarching "statement about people."

And maybe I didn't quite say this in the exact way that won't set people off the first time, but you know (or should know) that we have to do this A LOT. I was hoping to be able to skip it, but hey, guess not for now.

Re:Facebook Apologizes After A.I. Puts “Primates” Label on V... by pure_simplicity on Monday September 06, 2021 @10:28AM (#28434001)
No need to calm things down or thread needles, since I am rather stoic. You wanted interaction rather than downvotes, I gave you exactly that, so no need to complain about it being exhausting either.

The downvotes may have come from individuals who also think it would be helpful if you treated yourself and others as individuals rather than avatars of their racial collective. Your opinions are your opinions, there is nothing black or white about your opinion (in terms of skin color at least) or anyone else's opinions. There are white people that think like you, and there are black people that think unlike you.

Having a certain skin color doesn't make your opinion more valid or more worthy of being listened to either, even if you are in a demographic minority. For your opinion to be valid it has to have merit, so you have to back it up with good arguments that can convince a reasonable person. There's no racial cheat code we can/should insert into public discourse to bypass rational evaluation. That would be the bigotry of low expectations (you can't argue effectively for your case because of your identity, so we're gonna accept your conclusion because of your identity).

Shifting from the indefensible: "my opinions are absolutely related to my skin color and that's precisely why you all need to pay special attention to them" to the much milder and very different: "[it's] plausible that the lack of black folks in tech today is leading to unintended negative consequences", and glossing that over as "maybe I didn't quite say this in the exact way that won't set people off the first time", rather than admitting you were racially stereotyping yourself and (at least implicitly) other individuals is poor form. That's not a clarification, but a different argument. I think it's high time white leftists and leftist blacks confront their own racism, cuz that's the only form of socially acceptable racism that currently exists in the west.

Having said that, I think there's not much interesting about the hypothetical you raised. Changing the demographic composition of any group of people is almost certainly gonna change the distribution of opinions on the spectrum on any given topic, but that does not mean we are getting closer to truth. In the end, all that should matter is the facts and the arguments. That's why slavery and segregation were abolished at a time when blacks were vastly outnumbered in the population and in politics.

We don't need population level representation of blacks in tech (though it may be beneficial) to hold big tech accountable and achieve meaningful change, we just have to make the argument and raise awareness and reasonable people of all races will join in your cause if your argument has merit. Let's get back to MLK's ideal of color blindness, because those who are teaching us to see color are teaching us to hate each other.

Re:Facebook Apologizes After A.I. Puts “Primates” Label on V... by shashwatak on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @03:52AM (#28442143)
MLK did not preach “color blindness”, in fact he explicitly warned against the duplicity of “moderate whites” such as yourself.
Re:Facebook Apologizes After A.I. Puts “Primates” Label on V... by pure_simplicity on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @06:20AM (#28443024)
Conservative black, sorry. You failed the guessing game and proved my point that skin color correlates with opinion about as poorly as maths ability does (i.e. not meaningfully).

MLK preached judging by Character instead of Color, which is referred to as color blindness.

Also, the moderates of his era were moderate relative to the political landscape of their era. This is not a universal indictment, but a very culturally situated and contextually dependent statement, unlike the universal and timeless principle of color blindness.

Re:Facebook Apologizes After A.I. Puts “Primates” Label on V... by spennant on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @12:45PM (#28446915)
I read jrm4’s comment a little differently… It’s not that one’s skincolor correlates to opinion, but that it necessarily informs it. It’s pretty evident that people of similar skin tone and experiences may differ in opinion (just look at any family). Because of this, my takeaway wasn’t that it was the only thing that informed one’s opinion, but skin, as one of our society’s integral method for categorizing people, is intractable from the opinion forming process, particularly around matters concerning race.
Re:Facebook Apologizes After A.I. Puts “Primates” Label on V... by pure_simplicity on Monday September 13, 2021 @03:38PM (#28515781)
Skin color is a very passive trait. You can choose to make it as important or unimportant as you want. People who overemphasize skin color tend to be bad people. As such, I advise you to just not pay any attention to skin color, because as soon as you try to involve race or skin color in your judgment, you by definition become racist (no matter how well intentioned you think you are). The only way to not be racist is to leave race out of the equation and judge based on universal principles, thereby treating everyone equally (and we can debate which principles are universal).

Because of that, calling your opinion a black opinion is literally an invitation to your conversation partner to become racist in their judgment, since you are trying to get your conversation partner to focus on your race when they are considering your opinion. The only right way of treating that additional and unnecessary information is to ignore it, but if it can only rightly be ignored, then it shouldn't be shared in the first place since it is an impediment to constructive dialogue.

Skin color is as important as the paint job on your car: for some people it means the world, for some people it's just a paint job. It's liberating to not care about race, you should try it.

Re:Facebook Apologizes After A.I. Puts “Primates” Label on V... by jrm4 on Thursday September 16, 2021 @11:59AM (#28553449)
This is, without question, the most naive thing I have ever read on this entire site.

People will and do treat you differently because of your skin color. And how people treat you affects you, whether you think so or not. Either you live in a hole and never come out, or you haven't yet fully comprehended what's going on around you.

It's NOT simple. It's not "getting called names all the time" or anything like that. It takes time to fully get.

Re:Facebook Apologizes After A.I. Puts “Primates” Label on V... by pure_simplicity on Friday September 17, 2021 @06:12AM (#28563430)
I'm not denying that some bad people will treat you differently for your skin color. What I am saying is that how you respond to it is far more important than how people treat you (for most situations in our modern society, though some situations can be insurmountably overwhelming). Rather than me being naive, it is you being too black and white in your thinking when reading my comment (by making a false dilemma).

I've experienced neo-nazi racism against my person because of my skin color (and I mean literal self-identified neo-nazis, not merely a label given through the slanderous designation of some intolerant leftist). Despite those experiences, because I chose not to succumb to a mentality of victimhood those people's hateful attitude and behavior did not have the harmful effect on me it could have had.

However, if you believe that racism is as pervasive as the air we breathe, and the country is systemically racist, and white people suffer from implicit bias (and mysteriously it's only white people, kinda racist huh?) then I have to disagree. Racism exists, but the vast majority of people are good people. These days, the real racists (besides the tiny minority of actual white supremacists) are the so called 'anti-racists'. Their anti-white rhetoric to me is as appalling as the anti-black rhetoric of white supremacists. They forget the golden rule, don't do to others what you don't want done to you.

Re:Facebook Apologizes After A.I. Puts “Primates” Label on V... by shashwatak on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @08:30PM (#28451517)
Color-Blindness is not the same thing as Judging the Content of Character.

Of course, we all deserve to be judged based on the content of our character and not on superficial markers like skin, gender, etc, etc, etc.

However, broadly and statistically speaking, people from different economic and racial groups tend to have differing experiences, largely because of systems and not really because of any individual experience.

This is the core thesis of Critical Theory (and it’s subset Critical Race Theory): in the court of law, one must consider all of the details and context of a person, as they necessarily have an impact on an individual’s experiences.

Re:Facebook Apologizes After A.I. Puts “Primates” Label on V... by pure_simplicity on Monday September 13, 2021 @03:58PM (#28516024)
The moment you make race a factor in your judgment, by you have become racist by definition. The only right way to treat people is without regards to race / color, but by judging them according to universal principles.

The fundamental flaw of CRT is that it denies color-blindness. It doesn't matter that CRT claims to have good intentions for making race a factor in your judgment, it is still racist. The (progressive) eugenicists of yesteryear had good intentions too, but were horribly evil. Somehow progressives keep falling for the same trap and history keeps repeating itself. It's like racism is baked into their DNA. In every era they attempt to judge based on race and justify it with their ostensibly good intentions. It was racist then and it's racist now, but somehow the current iteration of left wing racism is just as socially acceptable and fashionable as every previous iteration.

Also I have a problem with the view that systems are the main reason for individual experiences. Two factors make up your life: your environment and your decisions. Your decisions are the most important part. No matter how good your environment, you can ruin your life by your decisions. No matter how bad your environment you can improve your life with your decisions. Constantly externalizing blame is a surefire way to short circuit the learning process that leads to self improvement. Having said that, I do agree that systems should be improved and tweaked, but it should be done carefully, because it's far easier to damage a reasonably effective complex system than to improve it.

Re:Facebook Apologizes After A.I. Puts “Primates” Label on V... by shashwatak on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @02:20AM (#28520964)
> The moment you make race a factor in your judgment, by you have become racist by definition.

This is not true. I just googled "racist" and it says "prejudiced against or antagonistic toward a person or people on the basis of their membership in a particular racial or ethnic group, typically one that is a minority or marginalized.".

Simply considering race doesn't automatically make it prejudiced or antagonistic.

And of course, there's also the concept of "structural racism", which is what CRT aims to help us dismantle.

Re:Facebook Apologizes After A.I. Puts “Primates” Label on V... by pure_simplicity on Friday September 17, 2021 @06:28AM (#28563564)
If you look up the definition of racism you find:

"Discrimination or prejudice based on race." - from The American Heritage® Dictionary of the English Language, 5th Edition.

Since discrimination based on race is racism, once you make race a factor in your judgment (even if it's one factor out of many) then you are discriminating based on race and therefore racist.

It doesn't matter if you are trying to help a specific race or hurt another race, privilege or oppression, they are two sides of the same racist coin. You may think you can justify your racism by appealing to historical racism, but it doesn't change the fact that you are being racist.

I happen to think that all racism is evil, I don't care about your intentions or which group it's directed at. After all, even Hitler claimed to have good intentions. There has yet to arise a racist that doesn't believe that he is doing something good. That's why I think trying to excuse some forms of racism while condemning others is arbitrary and hypocritical. Ends don't justify means. If you actually want to help people, find a way to do it that is not racist.

Edit: forgot to respond to CRT / structural racism

If by structural racism you mean anything other than laws/policies that are overtly racist or intentionally designed to target certain races despite having no overt racist language, then I agree that that is a problem. If you however conclude from a disparity in outcome that racial discrimination must be the cause of the disparity, then I think you are committing a logical fallacy (affirming the consequent).

The fallacious argument is:

(1) If there is structural racism then you will see disparity in outcome for different races. (2) there is disparity in outcome for different races (3) therefore there is structural racism

There can be any number of reasons to explain a disparity in outcomes across races. The existence of the disparity is not enough to prove racism. What I find is that the accusation of racism is made too easily, because there is political currency in victimhood. It's sad because tilting at windmills obstructs the actual progress that can be made at solving real problems, because we are distracted with thought-policing our white neighbors.

Re:Facebook Apologizes After A.I. Puts “Primates” Label on V... by jrm4 on Sunday September 05, 2021 @12:09PM (#28425361)
Said it before, saying it again. I merely said "pay special attention," not "always 100% agree." You've got two black folks here with differing opinions ostensibly ready to discuss. I have no problem with being disagreed with, but I'm still good suggesting that mere downvoting isn't helping.
Re:Facebook Apologizes After A.I. Puts “Primates” Label on V... by nzeribe on Saturday September 04, 2021 @07:44PM (#28420460)
I find it baffling and dispiriting that you, as a Black person, believe this is more likely to be an "error" than an act of deliberate racism. It's getting silly, now. A white racist programmer has done this on purpose because he finds it hilarious. The chances of a computer equating monkey and man, given the correct datasets, are close to nil. There's a blindness - a wilful ignorance - to look away and show good faith. Why is that?
Re:Facebook Apologizes After A.I. Puts “Primates” Label on V... by jpambrun on Saturday September 04, 2021 @10:52PM (#28421293)
As someone who worked on ml based classification I can totally see a man being misclassified as a monkey on occasion. If you have man and monkey in the output vector, it will happen on from time to time.. If you find a way to achieve 100% accuracy, go claim your Nobel prize..
Re:Facebook Apologizes After A.I. Puts “Primates” Label on V... by nzeribe on Sunday September 05, 2021 @08:16AM (#28423740)
But that's not what happened, is it? The algorithm hasn't miscategorised men, it has miscategorised Black men. I'd argue the AI has done its job, with a high degree of accuracy. It found what the programmers were looking for when they wrote the code. It was meant to be an insult, and was highly effective. Lack of outrage on HN is as expected; the authors are quite possibly in the comments holding their sides with laughter.
Re:Facebook Apologizes After A.I. Puts “Primates” Label on V... by jpambrun on Sunday September 05, 2021 @08:47AM (#28423953)
Those are baseless accusations based on poor understanding of ML.

This behaviour is counterproductive. It is not susceptible to sway me towards your point of view, but instead discredit you and those holding similar opinions.

Re:Facebook Apologizes After A.I. Puts “Primates” Label on V... by nzeribe on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @02:36AM (#28453808)
I am not here to "sway" you. Your hand-wavey dismissal is absurd, given the history of race in Silicon Valley. William Shockley was an out-and-out white supremacist. He goes on to form Shockley Semiconductor which begets Fairchild which becomes Intel. He set the culture. It is patently obvious that this outcome is likely written in code, and for you to dismiss this probability is absured. You have not discredited my position in any way, nor even attempted to challenge it. How on earth would you know if my understanding of ML is "poor" or otherwise? The joke in the code was to associate Black Men with monkeys. It is a trope that goes back hundreds of years. The joke is: "Look, even computers think Black men are primates" and that this position is objective, logical.
Re:Facebook Apologizes After A.I. Puts “Primates” Label on V... by jessaustin on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @02:31AM (#28441608)
Some people want to police AI behavior. Others want to police people's opinions of AI behavior.
Re:Facebook Apologizes After A.I. Puts “Primates” Label on V... by jrm4 on Sunday September 05, 2021 @11:01AM (#28424838)
Actually I now must strongly depart from your argument of intentionality here, and reiterate something I said before. I was about to respond to the person below, but they're more-or-less right. I don't know how intentional any of the programmers were here, so I'm not going to speculate on that.

But I will absolutely insist that this racist outcome is possible -- even likely -- absent any bad intentions from the programmer(s) who did it.

ALSO: I'm 99% sure of the following:

A black team of programmers working on "distinguishing humans from monkeys" would never let the mistake of "black and not white people identified as monkeys" out the door.

That's the point here. I'm not saying it wouldn't have happened somewhere in the process, I'm saying that you or I (if we don't work on the inside) would NEVER have seen it because it would have been noticed and fixed before then.

Re:Facebook Apologizes After A.I. Puts “Primates” Label on V... by nzeribe on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @02:45AM (#28453869)
Why wouldn't you assume intentionality as more likely than not given the disturbing history of race in Silicon Valley? The position you hold out of the gate is unlikely and your assumptions of good-faith are misplaced. William Shockley, who invented the transistor and essentially set up the Valley and it's culture, was an outright white supremacist. You see his legacy in the hiring percentages. The probability is that this was done on purpose. Your position is dangerous, in all honesty, because it sets up the idea that there is a logical similarity between Black Men and monkeys. "Look! Even a computer thinks so!" - and that we must modify outcomes so spare Black people's feelings. Note that the alleged error wasn't in distinguishing humans from monkeys as you state in error, but Black Men specifically.
Re:Facebook Apologizes After A.I. Puts “Primates” Label on V... by jrm4 on Friday September 10, 2021 @12:36PM (#28483934)
Primarily because my way is more forward looking and gets better results in the future, which is more important than punishing the past.

As I said before, I'm not here to smoke out old (or even current) racists individually. I don't think it's a valuable practice to "witch hunt" (even when the "witches" in this case are absolutely real and do exist.)

Because what that ends up doing is: every e.g. white person who's never said the n-word, or who has black people in their family, or has one black friend etc etc etc now subconsciously but completely lets themselves off the hook in any way. They get to think of themselves as superior because we've now defined racism as essentially a binary.

The above situation is mentally easier for many people (perhaps you as well) to deal with, rather than considering how deep this all goes.

Look, one wild thing you realize as a black person is that nearly everybody everywhere is to some extent surrounded by racism is that most everybody has some of it subconsciously internalized, and you don't fix it until you think about it directly, in yourself and others. I'm not a huge fan of "oh everybody's a little racist" because whoever says it is usually doing something dumb like excusing behavior -- but it's FAR closer to the truth than "if we smoke out the hidden but self-consciously racist people all will be fixed."

(so I suppose I'm saying -- yes, pay attention to what you are suggesting we pay attention to -- but also understand that it is almost CERTAINLY nowhere near sufficient to fix the problem.)

Re:Facebook Apologizes After A.I. Puts “Primates” Label on V... by jrm4 on Saturday September 04, 2021 @10:31PM (#28421217)
Yup. Though I would refine it a bit -- it's the "rush to excuse" that's the most dangerous. I don't much worry about the deliberate racist programmer as much as I worry about subconscious deliberate-or-not biases creeping in.

This perfectly analogizes to most everywhere else; angry open n-word saying racists are usually powerless losers.

More problems come from the larger combination of the rest of the "racism" spectrum, whether apathetic, or racist-but-quiet, or harbors latent biases that they may not know about etc.

(And here I do feel like I have to say, the answer isn't "SMOKE THEM OUT AND EXPOSE THEM" on the personal level, it's just taking the utmost care in the work you do)

Re:Facebook Apologizes After A.I. Puts “Primates” Label on V... by pure_simplicity on Sunday September 05, 2021 @10:32PM (#28429680)
In this case, it's not the rush to excuse that is dangerous, it's the rush to accuse that is dangerous. Innocent until proven guilty is a fundamental principle of justice. You have not demonstrated beyond reasonable doubt that this is in fact the doing of a racist, so anyone coming up with plausible alternative explanations is only doing so to prevent the discussion from devolving into a witch hunt where the guilt of the accused is simply assumed and our biases and perceptions stand in for evidence. Repeat the witch hunt scenario often enough and eventually you end up with a boy who cried wolf scenario and now you've lost your credibility even in cases where you do have evidence to back up your claims.

When people are careless in making accusations that's incredibly damaging to society. You as a black person should know how divisive and damaging false allegations can be, since that was a tool racists used to instill racial hostility in society. Let's not repeat those mistakes. I'm not saying racism doesn't exist or that we shouldn't do anything about it, but knowing in your heart of hearts that this must have been an act of deliberate racism is simply not enough. We need a smoking gun, or else it's best to withhold judgment.

The fact that no one thinks the mislabeling by the AI is acceptable should be enough. That shows you that no one would defend a person who deliberately designed this. The 'rush to excuse' is not because society doesn't want to condemn racism, but because most of society still cares about fairness and not making false accusations.

Re:Facebook Apologizes After A.I. Puts “Primates” Label on V... by jrm4 on Monday September 06, 2021 @10:18AM (#28433880)
If you follow who is saying what, I don't think you and I fundamentally disagree - or at least are not THAT far apart on this - I (the black person here who is still saying yep, my black opinion is important) have also been strongly suggesting that we not automatically attribute these problems to intentional racism.

So to clarify -- the "rush to excuse" that I'm saying is dangerous is really "the rush to insist that there is definitely no bias in play," NOT the "the rush to accuse individuals of being racist" -- and I suppose the fundamental problem I see going on here is that people can't seem to distinguish these two things, even though they are very different.

I'm going to keep saying this: the biggest problem is not smoking out hardcore racists who openly hate, the biggest problem is getting much of the non-black tech populace to even begin this conversation without the hypersensitivity kicking in (fully acknowledging that, while I'm not a fan of the terms "SJW" and "woke" and such, there also absolutely exists a naive liberal left that presently makes this conversation harder because they lean too hard into their particular direction)

Re:Facebook Apologizes After A.I. Puts “Primates” Label on V... by jrm4 on Sunday September 05, 2021 @12:06PM (#28425345)
And now I'm very curious as to the reasoning behind the downvotes. Again, I'm fine with you disagreeing with me, but I must insist that discussion is more valuable than blind downvotes when you do have the rare occasion of an actual real life black person here giving their opinion.