News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Has Agile Become Addiction to Instant Gratification? by PaulHoule on Saturday September 04, 2021 @09:26AM (#28414883)
I don’t buy that marshmallow experiment.

In an obesity crisis world aren’t you better off eating one marshmallow rather than two?

Re:Has Agile Become Addiction to Instant Gratification? by Comevius on Saturday September 04, 2021 @10:51AM (#28415628)
The marshmallow experiment is too simplistic, but for millions of years we usually were better off eating both marshmallows. Now we have supermarkets with products full of sugar. You can consume an unhealthy amount of sugar eating a few fitness granola bars, half a liter of fruit juice, or a single bar of chocolate.

We are especially vulnerable to superstimulus (exaggerated signals), which is what makes McDonalds, TikTok or surgically augmented breasts so popular. More sugar, more salt, more silly faces, more breasts. Even if we don't prefer them our brain is drawn to them. They used to be important signals. Youtube video thumbnails almost always feature people making faces, TikTok is short videos of people making faces. It's a race at providing better superstimulus. A lot of our culture these days is a constant bombardment of stimulus and we are not especially adapted to it.

Re:Has Agile Become Addiction to Instant Gratification? by GDC7 on Monday September 06, 2021 @11:20AM (#28434551)
> It's a race at providing better superstimulus

Couldn't agree more. if this trend continues, the only possible consequence is drugs becoming a form of art.

When external stimuli won't do it anymore people will seek to directly stimulate themselves with chemicals.

I think society would also find out that the risk benefit analysis of club drugs and LSD vs. social media and junk food is tilted heavily in favor of the former

Re:Has Agile Become Addiction to Instant Gratification? by kiba on Monday September 06, 2021 @11:38AM (#28434756)
I don't really buy the notion of superstimulus?

Why? McDonalds are not that delicious and I make better tasting burgers at home anyway.

Re:Has Agile Become Addiction to Instant Gratification? by test6554 on Monday September 06, 2021 @11:49AM (#28434875)
By the time someone realizes this they’ve already bought and taken a bite of the burger.

McDonald’s is not the best burger. But for the cost, speed, and effort involved, it’s pretty good.

We could make all kinds of things ourselves but largely we don’t.

Re:Has Agile Become Addiction to Instant Gratification? by Ceiling on Monday September 06, 2021 @11:48AM (#28434866)
I suspect the OP would argue that the stimulus you receive from McDonald’s is not the taste, but rather the variety, sugars, salts, ease, etc.
Re:Has Agile Become Addiction to Instant Gratification? by shantnutiwari on Monday September 06, 2021 @11:19AM (#28434536)
yeah the marshmallow experiment is too simplistic. I was reading somewhere that rather than measuring self-discipline, the researchers just measured which kids listened to the adults / did what they were told.
Re:Has Agile Become Addiction to Instant Gratification? by toss1 on Monday September 06, 2021 @12:11PM (#28435133)
Yup, as much as I like the idea behind the original analysis of the experiment, another likely insight is that it more effectively tested for socio-economic class.

For someone in a wealthy and stable environment, it is rational to wait 20min for the larger reward, as there is a high expectation that the promised event will occur as planned. However, in a poor and unstable environment, it is often more rational to take the bird-in-the-hand, as there is considerable uncertainty about whether the promised 2nd marshmallow will actually arrive.

Re:Has Agile Become Addiction to Instant Gratification? by bitwize on Monday September 06, 2021 @01:51PM (#28436213)
The marshmallow experiment was originally done on kids. A kid isn't going to get fat eating two marshmallows instead of one in a trial that's run once, and they're not going to have the forethought to decide to eat less rather than more because obesity epidemic anyway.