Re:Hardest amorphous material can scratch even diamond
by jacquesm on Friday September 03, 2021 @04:26PM
(#28408977)
Brittleness is arbitrarily defined as the ration between tensile and compressive strength so GP has a point (high compressive strength usually indicates a more brittle material), but without knowing the tensile strength it remains to be seen if it is more brittle or less brittle than say diamond.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Hardest amorphous material can scratch even diamond
by beerandt on Friday September 03, 2021 @05:04PM
(#28409398)
I don't think a single part of your comment is true.
ASCE, ASTM, and other professional orgs have non-arbitrary definitions. They are all versions of some measure of deformation at ultimate strength, but don't correlate to that strength value.
Crackers are brittle. Structural steel is not.
Re:Hardest amorphous material can scratch even diamond
by jacquesm on Saturday September 04, 2021 @05:27AM
(#28413515)
Yes, but this is an informal discussion, so that ratio actually serves a purpose unless you want to attach a complete course in materials science, it's 'good enough' for this level of discussion and sheds some light on why it is a thing to begin with. Oh, and just to fortify this comment here is a reference:
Re:Hardest amorphous material can scratch even diamond
by harpiaharpyja on Friday September 03, 2021 @04:34PM
(#28409074)
Diamond is quite brittle so I think to the point of the discussion, it's likely a brittle material even if it's somewhat less brittle than diamond.
Re:Hardest amorphous material can scratch even diamond
by beerandt on Friday September 03, 2021 @05:13PM
(#28409483)
Diamonds are actually tricky, because their practical brittleness is mostly due to breaks in the lattice caused by impurities. The lines of weakness are defined as cleavage, and diamonds will typically cleave along those lines when the break.
So there's a bit of ambiguity between the actual brittleness of the pure carbon structure and the practical brittleness where breaks in that structure naturally exist.