News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Surgical masks reduce Covid-19 spread, large-scale Stanfo... by chitowneats on Friday September 03, 2021 @01:49PM (#28407205)
From Martin Kulldorff, esteemed (though contrarian) Harvard Med epidemiologist:

"Odd that mask advocates are excited by this study. As a vaccine advocate, I would be horrified if a vaccine trial showed 11% efficacy. Based on the 95% confidence intervals, we do not even know if surgical mask efficacy is more than 0%."

https://twitter.com/MartinKulldorff/status/14332026511062016...

Re:Surgical masks reduce Covid-19 spread, large-scale Stanfo... by slg on Friday September 03, 2021 @01:56PM (#28407274)
Except that was not what was tested. Here is what they did:

>No-cost free masks distribution - One-third of the intervention villages received a cloth mask and two-thirds of the intervention villages received a surgical mask[5] during household distribution and distribution at marketplaces and other public locations weekly or every fortnight. Masks were also distributed at mosques on three Fridays during the first four weeks of the intervention.

>Offering information on mask-wearing - Along with the distribution, the research team showed a brief video of notable public figures discussing why, how, and when to wear a mask. The video featured the Honorable Prime Minister of Bangladesh Sheikh Hasina, the head of the national Imam Training Academy, and the national cricket star Shakib Al Hasan. During the distribution visit, households also received a brochure based on WHO materials depicting proper mask wearing.

>Reinforcement in-person and in public - In an effort to create a social norm, mask promoters encouraged non-mask wearers to wear a mask, providing a mask if the individual did not have one. Mask promoters also played public service announcements in public areas using handheld microphones.

>Modeling and endorsement by trusted leaders. - Religious leaders (imams) discussed the importance of mask-wearing at Friday prayers from a scripted speech provided by the research team.

This is a test of the effectiveness of these public policies and not the effectiveness of masks in general.

Re:Surgical masks reduce Covid-19 spread, large-scale Stanfo... by timr on Friday September 03, 2021 @02:27PM (#28407634)
They did all of those things, but this paper is about the effect of mask-wearing (surgical vs. cloth vs. none) on the rate of symptomatic seroprevalence in the groups. Kuldorff is right, and is just stating the top-line numbers from the paper.
Re:Surgical masks reduce Covid-19 spread, large-scale Stanfo... by slg on Friday September 03, 2021 @02:35PM (#28407720)
>Free mask distribution and promotion reduced the proportion of people who reported COVID-like symptoms on average by 11 percent, which was driven mainly by the effects of surgical masks. Villages where cloth masks were distributed experienced a 5 percent reduction in symptoms, while villages where surgical masks were distributed saw a reduction of 12 percent. About a third (40 percent) of those who reported COVID-19 symptoms agreed to have their blood tested for SARS-CoV-2. On average, researchers found a decrease of symptomatic SARS-CoV-2 infections of 9 percent. This reduction was higher in villages that wore a surgical mask (11 percent) and in these, among individuals aged 60+ (35 percent).

It is measuring the effectiveness of the public policy and comparing how it differs when the masks distributed were cloth versus surgical. There is nothing in this report about the effectiveness of masks on an individual level.

Re:Surgical masks reduce Covid-19 spread, large-scale Stanfo... by timr on Saturday September 04, 2021 @12:04AM (#28411978)
> There is nothing in this report about the effectiveness of masks on an individual level.

The DANMASK RCT [1] provided a direct test of masks as personal protective equipment, and found no support for masks. The criticism of that study, at that time, was that it didn't test the hypothesis of protecting others. So here we have an RCT that tests that hypothesis, and now that's not good enough, because the results aren't "at an individual level"?

Boy, the ground sure is slippery around here!

[1] https://www.acpjournals.org/doi/10.7326/M20-6817

Re:Surgical masks reduce Covid-19 spread, large-scale Stanfo... by worker767424 on Friday September 03, 2021 @03:18PM (#28408196)
And at 9%, some of that is likely seeing trusted public figures essentially saying "it's not safe out there" by talking about masks, and people restricting their actions accordingly. It's really hard to actually test this.
Re:Surgical masks reduce Covid-19 spread, large-scale Stanfo... by chitowneats on Friday September 03, 2021 @02:44PM (#28407824)
"This report" does gloss over much of the results from the actual study. Here's the link to the paper:

https://www.poverty-action.org/sites/default/files/publicati...

Re:Surgical masks reduce Covid-19 spread, large-scale Stanfo... by kragen on Friday September 03, 2021 @02:17PM (#28407511)
Hmm, are you suggesting that those public policies might have had an impact on covid transmission that wasn't mediated through mask-wearing? For example, having the imams discuss the importance of mask-wearing might discourage people from going to Friday prayers? That seems unlikely but conceivable.
Re:Surgical masks reduce Covid-19 spread, large-scale Stanfo... by slg on Friday September 03, 2021 @02:35PM (#28407721)
>Hmm, are you suggesting that those public policies might have had an impact on covid transmission that wasn't mediated through mask-wearing?

That wasn't the intention of my comment, but yes that is also true. As the article notes:

>"In the intervention villages, they also saw a slight increase in physical distancing in public spaces, such as marketplaces."

My original comment was more directed at the fact that these public policies are not 100% effective in getting people to wear masks. Therefore the society reduction of 11% is not comparable to the vaccine efficacy numbers which are measured at an individual level. If we measured vaccine efficacy numbers using this societal approach, the numbers in the US would be abysmal considering our active case numbers are quickly approaching the peak of the pre-vaccine waves.

Re:Surgical masks reduce Covid-19 spread, large-scale Stanfo... by Volundr on Friday September 03, 2021 @02:34PM (#28407713)
Not really. What's being suggested is that what's being tested is both societal compliance combined with mask effectiveness. To dramatically over simplify, let's assume we have a population of 10, none of them mask wearers. Let's also assume masks are 100% effective at preventing Covid infection. These measures convince only 1 person to wear a mask.

In the control group (no advocacy) 10/10 are infected. In the study group 9/10 are because that one person wore a mask. So we've got an effectiveness of 10%, despite masks in our contrived example being 100% effective. The effectiveness is blunted by lack of compliance.

Re:Surgical masks reduce Covid-19 spread, large-scale Stanfo... by dragontamer on Friday September 03, 2021 @01:56PM (#28407269)
EDIT: Woops, read wrong. Lemme post the quote instead.

> The observers found that just over 13% of people in the villages that received no interventions wore a mask properly, compared with more than 42% of people in the villages where each household received free masks and in-person reminders to wear them

So an increase of 13% masking to 42% masking led to an 11% effective drop in COVID19 spread. So even though 70% of people weren't affected (either the 13% who wore a mask anyway, or the 60% of people who ignored the mask advice), you still had a measurable decrease in COVID19 spread.

Which means masking mandates / masking propaganda works. Even with the huge number of people who ignore it, its still an effective means to cut down on COVID19 spread.

Re:Surgical masks reduce Covid-19 spread, large-scale Stanfo... by input_sh on Friday September 03, 2021 @01:56PM (#28407275)
And then see this response to that claim by one of the study's authors: https://mobile.twitter.com/Jabaluck/status/14331294449405992...
Re:Surgical masks reduce Covid-19 spread, large-scale Stanfo... by kragen on Friday September 03, 2021 @02:04PM (#28407351)
Re:Surgical masks reduce Covid-19 spread, large-scale Stanfo... by input_sh on Friday September 03, 2021 @05:51PM (#28409823)
I wouldn't really call it better if it doesn't have a proper certificate.
Re:Surgical masks reduce Covid-19 spread, large-scale Stanfo... by barbazoo on Friday September 03, 2021 @02:01PM (#28407315)
which seems to have been deleted in the meantime
Re:Surgical masks reduce Covid-19 spread, large-scale Stanfo... by SubiculumCode on Friday September 03, 2021 @01:55PM (#28407261)
I think this thread is a decent refutation that the CI lower bound was at 0:

"First, the 11% reduction comes from a 30% increase in mask-use. The IV estimate (naively scaling things linearly) would thus be more like a 37% reduction in COVID from going from zero to universal masking."

"Second, we find much larger effects among the elderly (a 35% reduction among 60+ without the above scaling). This suggests that the total reduction in morbidity and mortality from universal masking may be considerably larger than even the 37% number, perhaps more than 50%."

"Third, it's not quite an apples to apples comparison because we are estimating the community impact of masks, whereas the vaccine studies only isolate the individual protective effect. The efficacy of vaccines at the population level may be larger than trials imply."

https://twitter.com/Jabaluck/status/1433129444940599296

Re:Surgical masks reduce Covid-19 spread, large-scale Stanfo... by rafaelero on Friday September 03, 2021 @02:10PM (#28407418)
Is this guy serious? It was not a split between 100% of group A using masks and 0% of group B using it. It was more like 40% / 15%. Is it that easy to become a tenure in Harvard? I think I am applying.
Re:Surgical masks reduce Covid-19 spread, large-scale Stanfo... by weaksauce on Friday September 03, 2021 @02:03PM (#28407344)
because compliance was voluntary... the study merely had leaders in the community wear masks and provided free masks to those that wanted them plus education and reminders; it wasn't a compulsory thing so this is mainly a lower bound on effectiveness.

> Providing free masks, informing people about the importance of covering both the mouth and nose, reminding people in-person when they were unmasked in public, and role-modeling by community leaders tripled regular mask usage compared with control villages that received no interventions, the researchers found.