Performance and public perception are not the same thing. One is much more steady and less susceptible to wild and capricious swings than the other.
Most people have a fairly stable level of performance over time, except when dramatic or destructive events or behaviour interfere (such as drug abuse, stock market crashes, etc.) The millions of people who are stably employed and have been for years are clear evidence of this. If past performance was not an indicator of future performance, then work experience, resumes, and criminal histories are all meaningless.
Past performance is evidence for the consistency of present behaviour.
For every famous artist who struggled and then made it big, there are thousands of artists who were treated the same initially but really were crap. That's because a huge number of people want to be artists and 90% of everything is crap.
Now suppose that you are trying to make money by enabling artists, and it costs $10,000 to give one a try. If you take a chance on everyone, you will go broke because 90% of everything is crap and your few famous artists won't be enough to subsidize the rest.
So how do you filter?
Or take a look at music bands. First few albums are smashing hits, then suddenly, no more takers. Everything they create is simply not accepted by the fans. The mojo is gone.
Perhaps startups are a bit less fragile, or I just don't know enough history, but I think similar patterns emerge if you look widely enough.
edit: actually, We Live In Public (movie) could be a good example. Josh Harris had a really really successful first venture, after the web1.0 crash, nothing he tried doing really caught on and became something. At the end of the movie about him, he's hiding from creditors in africa or something.