Re:Take-Two Sues Enthusiasts Behind GTA Fan Projects Re3 and...
by everyone on Friday September 03, 2021 @10:20AM
(#28404569)
Legal department / managers etc. needed something to do.
Re:Take-Two Sues Enthusiasts Behind GTA Fan Projects Re3 and...
by jrm4 on Friday September 03, 2021 @10:30AM
(#28404673)
IAAL, and this is actually pretty accurate. Also of note, there is a princple within the law that basically suggests "if you don't vigorously defend your IP, that can be taken to mean you don't much care in the future as well." Honestly, in our modern environment, I don't find that much compelling (as something to really worry about from a developer POV), but it does exist.
Re:Take-Two Sues Enthusiasts Behind GTA Fan Projects Re3 and...
by yjftsjthsd-h on Friday September 03, 2021 @11:03AM
(#28405140)
> a princple within the law that basically suggests "if you don't vigorously defend your IP, that can be taken to mean you don't much care in the future as well."
I thought that was only trademarks?
Re:Take-Two Sues Enthusiasts Behind GTA Fan Projects Re3 and...
by jrm4 on Friday September 03, 2021 @12:28PM
(#28406287)
You may be right that, for now, that's where its mostly clearly stated..but..
I don't do much IP personally, but I'm familiar enough to have seen that a lot of people, even judges, don't always draw those technical clear lines between different types of IP. So, going both ways -- it's not unthinkable that someone would try to
1) apply this reasoning but with copyright and/or
2) claim (if flimisily) that this is trademark infringement, despite it not exactly fitting with how the law is supposed to work.
Re:Take-Two Sues Enthusiasts Behind GTA Fan Projects Re3 and...
by kjrose on Friday September 03, 2021 @12:56PM
(#28406626)
Doesn't the fallout from this like make it a bad thing to do though? They are pretty much attacking their biggest fans. I am pretty sure that's generally not a good idea from a marketing standpoint.
Is there some sort of IP reason, like they need to defend the IP lest it be marked as being abandoned? Or is there some other legit reason beyond spite that they are taking this on? I dont see Take-Two losing any significant amount of income from this enthusiast project, but I could be wrong and I am willing to be corrected.