so it seems at least possible that there is some collusion, conscious or not, between journalists and cybersecurity spooks to name an enemy in order to get traction in the public mind, vs. saying "well, it's from a lot of different people, lots of stuff from china, and who knows what else."
I even think this might be a good strategy - I guess my point is i'd like to see more real public evidence before we accuse foreign governments of attacking us in the press. not because i don't believe it is happening, but because i feel those assertions should be backed up if they're going to be made.
Exactly -- it's pretty easy to rent a chinese box from one of the many botnets out there, and I guess that would be the first choice of an intruder to hide his trails.
Would you also limit your targets to things that would seem to be of overwhelming interest to the chinese government?
US defense contractors; the governments of US, Canada, Vietnam, South Korea, Taiwan, and India; Democracy/Human Rights groups; mining, security, electronics, power companies.
That seems like an unlikely target list for someone who's in it for the 'lulz'.
Frankly, what's more alarming; the dedicated resources of a single state actor, or a complex, emergent network of self-interested individuals and groups persuing their own aims?
I find the Chinese explanation a little too convenient and a little too amenable to typical national defense thinking. What this article really says to me is that if you want to hack an American company, own a Chinese box first. Nobody will look any further.