Re:Aaron Swartz: How To Launch Software
by inklesspen on Friday August 22, 2008 @07:53PM
(#284332)
I think people hated it because there was nothing there.
He promised that Infogami would revolutionize making webpages the way that the Macintosh revolutionized the computer industry.
What he delivered was another wiki. I can't believe PG thought this was worth investing in.
Infogami was very much a Hollywood launch. He did almost exactly what 37signals suggested. He posted a teaser as soon as he got into the YCombinator program. He had mavens and insiders try out the product (I think; I can't imagine PG not trying out a YC startup's product before launch and showing it to his friends). And then he launched with a big splash.
And people hated it.
I suspect that product quality has far more bearing on startup success than how you launch. And as you say, the difference between 37signals and Aaron Schwartz is ability to execute. But Aaron's advice is a good way to find out if you haven't yet executed well and improve the product before everyone else finds out.