Re:Apple and Google must allow other in-app payment systems,...
by zrm on Wednesday September 01, 2021 @01:41AM
(#28376722)
Volume discounts come about because the true cost of a product has both fixed and variable components. If it costs a given amount to have a checkout clerk ring up your order, that amount doesn't change based on whether you buy a case of ramen or a single cup, so if you buy the case they can spread it over a larger volume.
But in this context, the fixed and variable costs are already split out. iOS developers pay the $99 fixed charge that should cover any of Apple's fixed costs and pay 30%. If you're already paying the fixed costs explicitly then the unit price only needs to cover the variable costs and higher volume yields no change.
And they're starting off from a PR hole because the rate so obviously has no relationship to their actual costs. It costs them the same to distribute a 100MB app whether the developer charges $1 or $100, but they charge $0.30 in one case and $30 in the other. A developer with a 10MB app sold for $10 pays ten times more than a developer with a 100MB app sold for $1 even though their distribution cost to Apple is ten times less.
Ordinary competitive markets don't work like that because otherwise a competitor would come in charging prices more proportional to their costs and everyone being overcharged would switch to the alternative.
But in this context, the fixed and variable costs are already split out. iOS developers pay the $99 fixed charge that should cover any of Apple's fixed costs and pay 30%. If you're already paying the fixed costs explicitly then the unit price only needs to cover the variable costs and higher volume yields no change.
And they're starting off from a PR hole because the rate so obviously has no relationship to their actual costs. It costs them the same to distribute a 100MB app whether the developer charges $1 or $100, but they charge $0.30 in one case and $30 in the other. A developer with a 10MB app sold for $10 pays ten times more than a developer with a 100MB app sold for $1 even though their distribution cost to Apple is ten times less.
Ordinary competitive markets don't work like that because otherwise a competitor would come in charging prices more proportional to their costs and everyone being overcharged would switch to the alternative.