Re:Lively, Google’s virtual world, has been a flop
by ivankirigin on Friday August 22, 2008 @10:41AM
(#283718)
Once again, google stumbles with something remotely social. They really need to stop thinking algorithm is king for non-search products. Also, I've heard many anecdotes of designers being treated as second class citizens. That has to stop.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Lively, Google’s virtual world, has been a flop
by gruseom on Friday August 22, 2008 @12:44PM
(#283860)
Interesting. Algorithm is king and underestimating design: those do sound like two distinctive Google weaknesses. If so, I'd be surprised if they stop. These are the sorts of things that get baked into cultural DNA early on and tend not to change.
Edit: At the same time, these have been two of Google's greatest strengths (in their core context).
Re:Lively, Google’s virtual world, has been a flop
by prakash on Friday August 22, 2008 @10:48AM
(#283724)
They really need to stop thinking algorithm is king for non-search products.
Source or Is this just anecdotal evidence? I do agree with you that a better algorithm doesn't guarantee an automatic win.
Re:Lively, Google’s virtual world, has been a flop
by ivankirigin on Friday August 22, 2008 @01:32PM
(#283930)
Generally, the company is engineering driven. This is well known.
A product manager / designer friend of mine was asked to code on a white board during an interview. That is retarded.
Re:Lively, Google’s virtual world, has been a flop
by prakash on Friday August 22, 2008 @03:03PM
(#284062)
cool. thanks.
Re:Lively, Google’s virtual world, has been a flop
by marketer on Friday August 22, 2008 @12:54PM
(#283872)
They're smart though. I'm sure it wouldn't take long for them to realize they're clueless about the social aspects of the virtual world, and start hiring social media/game consultants. Look no further than Microsoft, who bought Bungee in anticipation for the Xbox.
Re:Lively, Google’s virtual world, has been a flop
by ivankirigin on Friday August 22, 2008 @01:30PM
(#283926)
Orkut has taken years, and has had little to no traction in the country where google has many thousands of employees.
Also, xbox was a core play for microsoft. It is the computer in the living room now, which is huge. Online virtual worlds in the browser aren't nearly as core. My point is that I wouldn't expect them to invest heavy resources in M&A in this area.