> What freedoms are missing that you would like to see added?
I am not so small a mind to be concerned with semantics debates and the definition of “freedom”.
Purely in the sense of what I personally desire, as in rational egotism, I would wish for all software to exist for me free of charge, with all source code available, with a copious options system, and that it be written in a programming language I am competent in and follows the style guides I find easiest to reaed.
That is a wish, not a moral dogma; moral dogmata are Stallman's domain and I consider any man who would seriously believe that things can be morally right or wrong to be of quæstionable rationality.
> You are conflating GCC as free software with software created using GCC as a compiler.
I'm doing no such thing; I'm simply pointing out that the G.C.C. would probably not be free software without the exception.
> The runtime exception has been in place for quite a while and is part of the reason why GCC is very widely used.
> I would argue that the four freedoms are also part of the reason why GCC has been so successful.
I'm fairly certain it's the biggest reason is simply that it's a very good and gratis compiler.
>> Anyone can decree that one of those is not important, or add a fifth.
Freedom 0: The freedom to run the program as you wish, for any purpose
Freedom 1: The freedom to study how the program works, and change it so it does your computing as you wish. (Access to the source code is a precondition for this.)
Freedom 2: The freedom to redistribute copies so you can help others.
Freedom 3: The freedom to distribute copies of your modified versions to others. (Access to the source code is a precondition for this.)
Which freedoms do you disagree with and why?
What freedoms are missing that you would like to see added?
>> The G.C.C. had to be given a licence exception for the runtime it links against, otherwise arguably anything compiled with it would become a derivative product of it, and thus subject to the G.P.L.
You are conflating GCC as free software with software created using GCC as a compiler.
The runtime exception has been in place for quite a while and is part of the reason why GCC is very widely used.
I would argue that the four freedoms are also part of the reason why GCC has been so successful.