News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Non-Commercial Licenses Are Non-Free Licenses by kumarsw on Tuesday August 31, 2021 @08:17AM (#28366953)
Non-commercial clauses seem to be a good fit for software that is someone's "day job" where they charge for licenses. It's not common, but I've run across the following projects:

Duplicacy by Gilbert Chen https://github.com/gilbertchen/duplicacy

Dome by Federico Milano http://faraday1.ucd.ie/dome.html

Fman by Michael Herrmann https://fman.io

From what I've gathered, success has been mixed. Duplicacy seems to be doing well based on forum activity and release history. Fman never made much money. If I recall correctly the Fman author was turned off by the number of people who criticized it for being fully open-source and wished he'd stuck with a closed-source full commercial model. I'd like for the open-source community to be more accepting of this model as there is potential value in it. As an example, Mathematica still refuses to let anyone not employed by the company see the source code, which creates a reproducibility/validation problem for math researchers. While Steven Wolfram understandably rejects pleas to make the software FOSS, there is real benefit in letting people see the code.

Edit: Fixed names

Re:Non-Commercial Licenses Are Non-Free Licenses by mherrmann on Tuesday August 31, 2021 @08:30AM (#28367113)
Michael Herrmann. Thank you for the mention ;-)

The post you mentioned about being criticized for not being open source: https://fman.io/blog/dear-comrade/

Re:Non-Commercial Licenses Are Non-Free Licenses by ghaff on Tuesday August 31, 2021 @08:24AM (#28367036)
It's effectively what you had in the Freeware for personal use only and Shareware (supposed to pay after a trial period) worlds. In practice, it was mostly companies that paid. When I had a small shareware business about half my revenues came from site licensing and the rest were split between individuals and companies.

The software wasn't open source but, as a practical matter, for solo developer projects it worked pretty much the same way.

Re:Non-Commercial Licenses Are Non-Free Licenses by Macha on Tuesday August 31, 2021 @08:32AM (#28367141)
> Duplicacy by Raymond Chen

Gilbert Chen is a different person to Raymond Chen, unless I'm missing something?