Re:Non-Commercial Licenses Are Non-Free Licenses
by rossy on Tuesday August 31, 2021 @09:27AM
(#28367790)
I think this is where I disagree. I'm all for identifying corporate exploitation of free software, but this isn't it. If I work to enrich the commons, and as a result someone profits, I don't think harm has been done to me. Sure, it might feel bad to know that someone is profiting because of my work and they couldn't spare anything for me, but ultimately, I didn't expect to make any money when I did the work. I would have done it anyway. It's really hard to see how I've been harmed here.
Re:Non-Commercial Licenses Are Non-Free Licenses
by ddevault on Tuesday August 31, 2021 @08:04AM
(#28366826)
You can make that case, and you're entitled to distribute your software under terms that prevent this.
But this is the deal you sign up for when you make free and open source software. If you want to make another kind of software, that's quite fine, but it's not free software nor open source.
Re:Non-Commercial Licenses Are Non-Free Licenses
by Macha on Tuesday August 31, 2021 @08:41AM
(#28367247)
Especially if your complaint is "We got lots of growth because people adopted our open source software but then Amazon published a hosted version and now we can't claim as much of the commercial opportunity, so we need a more restrictive license."
Would the software have attained the userbase it did if they were the terms from the outset? A lot of these companies just assume that it would have been the exact same except for the absence of an amazon competitor if these licenses were used.
Or at least a labourer may legitimately claim they wish to share "freely" only to some. And they can also choose to change their mind on any subsequent work.
This is especially the case when the entities involved are corporate, not individual humans.