Re:Patents against prosperity
by anghyflawn on Tuesday August 02, 2011 @04:10AM
(#2836310)
Re your case in point 1, it is precisely this thinking that they want to exploit. "They wouldn't be suing us if they didn't have a case, so let's just settle". Except that if it actually comes to court, chances are it'll be thrown out within a minute.
Minor point: this is a blog entry, not an article. I don't believe "The Economist" holds their blogs to the same standard as their articles. Certainly the voice and formality is more relaxed in their blogs.
Case In Point 1: If the company suing Spotify is truly a patent troll (i.e. a non-practicing entity), then buying into IV's patent fund would not help them. Having defensive patents only works when the aggressor has a line of business that could be threatened with patent infringement.
Case In Point 2: I have to take issue with Lemley's critique of simultaneous invention. To name two high-profile cases, consider the Bell-Gray simultaneous invention of the telephone, or Dow and Exxon's slugfest over metallocene-catalyzed polyethylene patent protection in the late 1990's.