News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:MarkMonitor left 60k domains for the taking by detaro on Sunday August 29, 2021 @08:56PM (#28351890)
it doesn't verify control over the CNAME from the person creating the bucket, that's the criticism, instead it lets any AWS user claim it. (The usual verification method would be something like requiring a TXT record to be set with a secret that's tied to the bucket, and I guess for route53 users they could integrate settings from there)
Re:MarkMonitor left 60k domains for the taking by fastball on Sunday August 29, 2021 @10:40PM (#28352353)
Right, but the owner of the domain needs to create a CNAME record that points to AWS for a bucket they don't control. How is that not purely on them?
Re:MarkMonitor left 60k domains for the taking by detaro on Sunday August 29, 2021 @10:59PM (#28352435)
If thousands of people keep making a mistake when using your product, you can go "purely on them, not our problem", true. Or you can do something to your product to make the mistake less likely to cause a problem.
Re:MarkMonitor left 60k domains for the taking by Sebb767 on Monday August 30, 2021 @01:30AM (#28353025)
The bucket can be created before they can do so, which is exactly what happened to MarkMonitor here. Now, technically you could create the bucket first before setting the CNAME, but this can quickly go wrong (especially when handling hundreds of domains) and it regularly does. There's no need to keep this footgun around.
Re:MarkMonitor left 60k domains for the taking by ctvo on Monday August 30, 2021 @08:36AM (#28354984)
S3 is not a CDN. S3 is a distributed file system. Use a CDN for CDN use cases (CloudFront) and you wouldn't have these issues.

There's a chance a normal AWS user may not understand the above distinction, a sophisticated actor like MarkMonitor (whose business is THIS) should. Instead they had a security incident. That's it. They used the wrong AWS service. They configured massive numbers of domain DNS records incorrectly. They risked their customer's reputations.