«[...] This all sounds quite risky. Does it mean that we should avoid prescription medicines entirely? Let’s look at the most common adverse-reaction offenders. Anti-seizure drugs, insulin, and blood-thinning medications—often used to prevent stroke—are at the top of the list; antibiotics account for more adverse effects than almost any other kind of drug, leading to approximately a hundred and fifty thousand E.R. visits annually; even acetaminophen turns out to be risky, causing fifty-six thousand E.R. visits, twenty-six hundred hospitalizations, nearly half of all liver failures, and over four hundred and fifty deaths each year. Nevertheless, I think that most of my vaccine-hesitant patients would agree that preventing strokes and seizures, treating diabetes, alleviating pain, and curing infections are extremely important, and that the benefits we derive from using these medications weigh favorably against their risks.»
A binary dilemma is expressed in the paragraph, while the actual topic is ternary. «Most of [his] vaccine-hesitant patients» would take insulin as a better option than just bearing diabetes, but not necessarily would take farmaceutical prophylaxis over a relatively high isolation (if they can afford it in practice - The New Yorker was not exactly born for a public of dwellers in low density areas).
It's partly the weakness of pro-vaccine articles like this one that fuels the phenomenon. People read it and say, is that the best counter-argument there is? Then perhaps my hesitation is correct indeed.
If the source of damages is similar with infection or vaccination, and if the vulnerability depended on one's specific body, if you may suffer a hit after the latter, imagine the blow you could get after the former.
About instead the article and its "reassurances to hesitants": its honest report of the risks of very common medicines will be an eye opener to those who thought of medicines as "innocuous candies not worth considerate approach".
If you read the underlying papers it seems to be just assumed that one is much less than the other because that's how vaccines normally work, and it'd be insane if it were not the case. But this is new technology, and these vaccines aren't acting like vaccines are meant to e.g. they don't seem to stop you catching it and getting sick, their effectiveness seems to last months rather than decades, and their side effects are much worse.
I have become quite suspicious about this over time because I keep encountering people who say the vaccine made them sick, and the symptoms align very closely with COVID symptoms. Recovery appears to be a little faster but perhaps not by much - the only person in my immediate social circle who actually definitely got COVID was only in bed for a day, and then it took several days to shake off the remnants of the cough. The vaccines don't give people a cough but "It laid me low for a day or two, felt so sick I had to stay in bed all day" is a very common side effect. This is what you'd expect if the vaccine was doing the same stuff as the virus itself but without filling the lungs with crap. And that's in turn what you'd expect given the way the mRNA vaccines actually work: they cause cells to act infected and the immune system then detects them as such. Whether vaccines cause more or less damage than a viral infection very much depends on the relative areas under the curves and the relative value of different kinds of cells that are exposed and destroyed, but, again, no way to actually get data into that form.
But then you weight it by incidence. Governments seem to have a bloody minded fanatical determination to make vaccine incidence 100% by any means possible. On the other hand, where I live, after a year and a half of this stuff, only ~10% of the population has tested positive. When the person I live with got sick, I was forced to self-isolate with them, and I never got sick even though delta is supposedly super infectious. The incidence of the virus is far less than the incidence of vaccines, so even if their impact is within a similar order of magnitude (i.e. much less but still comparable), it seems quite plausible that the vaccines end up making more people sick than the virus (for some value of "the virus" given that it mutates and "the vaccine" given the apparent need for repetitive boosters).
You're making a couple assumptions here which don't hold true in practice. (1) That "skeptic" concerns are uniform. Those may be your important concerns, but they're not for others. (2) That you'll be able persuade "skeptics" by logically addressing their concerns. You can't reason someone out of a position they didn't reason themselves into.
"holdout" and "well-informed" are mutually incompatible in this scenario.
You're trying to lump people who have legitimate concerns about the covid-19 vaccine in particular with the vaccines cause autism/magnetic vaccines crowd, and it's very dishonest. This is not some monolithic movement, and I disavow the people who are anti-vax in principle.
I'm rooting for the covid vaccines, and I hope they're everything we've been promised and more, but I will be waiting.
There are no such "legitimate concerns" (or legitimate arguments for that matter). You trying to lump people that are delusional, uneducated, fear-mongering deniers in with rational people that evaluate reality on its own merits is the "very dishonest" part.
Are the vaccinated experiencing adverse reactions?
Have vaccines in the past been proven to be dangerous? Looking at you anthrax vaccine.
None of these are zero.
If you can pass the throng test and argue why their might be hesitancy, it would make you more understanding.
No.
> Are the vaccinated experiencing adverse reactions?
Occasionally people will experience mild adverse reactions. This is actually covered in the article above.
However, adverse vaccine reactions are happening at a much lower rate than actual DEATH of healthy individuals from Covid19 itself. Let along "long covid" symptoms.
> Have vaccines in the past been proven to be dangerous? Looking at you anthrax vaccine.
Gulf war syndrome has not been established to be caused by the anthrax vaccine. So no.
> None of these are zero.
They don't have to be zero, but 0.0003 is a much smaller number than the adverse reactions to catching Covid itself.
> If you can pass the throng test and argue why their might be hesitancy, it would make you more understanding.
I don't know what "the throng test" is but I don't think WE are the ones that do not understand. It is you who does not understand.
The fact you site a conspiracy theory about gulf war syndrome makes me believe you are not being honest.
Perhaps this explains a lot of the more fanatical aspects of those pushing vaccines-for-all. There are absolutely people dying of the vaccine, and who were at very low risk of dying of COVID. For example, this TV presenter:
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2021/08/26/bbc-presenter-di...
"A BBC presenter died from a blood clot on the brain due to complications of the AstraZeneca Covid-19 vaccine, a coroner has concluded. Lisa Shaw died in May, just over three weeks after she had her first dose of the jab, an inquest in Newcastle heard on Thursday."
Although that article admits the connection, usually media reports about people who died shortly after taking their vaccine simply don't mention it at all. Like this teenager:
https://alexberenson.substack.com/p/simone-scott-oct-7-2001-...
The parents worked with Berensen on the story and confirmed on Twitter that it is fully real. But if you search the name Simone Scott on Google you will be given lots of news articles that didn't talk to the parents, and which claim she died of a "mysterious illness" or even "a virus" (unnamed). In other words, vaccine-linked deaths are going unreported or outright misreported, with rare exceptions like famous TV personalities.
Or this hip hop artist who died at 42 of a heart attack, 28 days after being vaccinated (heart attacks being a known side effect). None of the news articles about his death mention the proximity to the vaccine: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/aug/16/a-linchpin-tri... and https://www.bitchute.com/video/GIe8s0JTv7rG/ has tweets showing his date of vaccination.
The VAERS database tracks reports of deaths that occur shortly after being vaccinated.
https://www.openvaers.com/covid-data/mortality
Look at the graph of reports of death by onset in days. Most deaths occur on the day of the vaccination or within just a few days later, strongly suggesting causality, especially as only the most motivated people will learn how to report to VAERS - it's optional, people are not being informed about it ahead of time, and there are many reports of the health system refusing to help file reports.
Today there was a report that COVID vaccines are ~100x as deadly as flu vaccines. It's behind a paywall so I haven't read it, but it sounds plausible when you look at the numbers. Deaths are obviously not the only problem that can arise. Many people are reporting injuries of various kinds, sometimes quite serious ones. Browse the reports on the site to see for yourself.
At any rate, there has never been any question that some people will be killed or maimed by the vaccine in such a large rollout. Even Bill Gates admitted that right at the start. These things are always cost/benefit calculations. The question is what exactly is the cost. In the current environment of absolute hostility to anything that could slow down the rollout, it's very unclear anyone really knows.
That is just wrong and any good doctor can explain that to you, you seem to be badly informed here.
There are risk calculations that favor vaccination with all currently available knowledge. But there are secondary issues like vaccine surveillance and compelling medical treatments that might nudge people in different directions. These are legitimate since the behavior of the most militant vaccine proponents are fairly predictable.
So I ask, what will it take for you to change your mind? What is the evidence you are waiting for that does not already exist?
Given that as of September Israel will only consider people fully vaccinated if they've had a booster injection, I don't believe this criteria has yet been met.
It's not even like an annual flu shot at this point, as people who were considered fully vaccinated just a couple of months ago now need further boosters.
At this stage it looks like the taxpayer will be footing the bill for twice-annual booster shots for everyone. This is just not sustainable
Isn't it? Not speaking to its wisdom, but it seems entirely sustainable from a financial perspective - some napkin math suggests that the all-in costs of that frequency of vaccination would be <1% of the federal budget of a typical developed country.
- Role of age, fitness and comorbidities in risk/benefit analysis - Lack of trust in institutions (suppression of alternative views; capture/corruption)
Another question is who New Yorker can reach, I won't be surprised that ~95% of their audience are already vaccinated. And remaining 5% holdouts are well-informed and would need way better arguments.