News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: We built an end-to-end encrypted alternative to ... by explodingcamera on Sunday August 29, 2021 @11:48AM (#28347649)
This is looks super cool, however not something I'd be interested in using myself if I can't selfhost it (at least it looks like thats not possible from the website).
Re:Show HN: We built an end-to-end encrypted alternative to ... by YPPH on Sunday August 29, 2021 @11:57AM (#28347755)
Self-hosting a zero knowledge service is probably unnecessary.

If you're hosting the service, there's no need for data to be encrypted client-side. Unless, of course, you were intending on running the service on a public cloud which you didn't control, but that's something I don't think many privacy conscious folk would do.

There's plenty of open source, self-hosted alternatives to Google Photos.

Re:Show HN: We built an end-to-end encrypted alternative to ... by sam0x17 on Sunday August 29, 2021 @12:59PM (#28348401)
Yeah, having attempted to operate a service very similar to this (only more focused on general encrypted cloud storage) I will say there are no good economics in usage-based billing. You're much better off selling a license to use the software and give users the ability to use common cloud storage providers (minimally the s3-compatible ones but also things like Google Drive) as the backing for this. Even safer from a legal perspective would be not having accounts at all and allowing users to purchase a 1-year license based on license keys that are cryptographically validated but not stored anywhere. Then it's impossible to do anything user specific whether you are compelled to or not.
Re:Show HN: We built an end-to-end encrypted alternative to ... by cdata on Sunday August 29, 2021 @12:21PM (#28348018)
To me it is a canary signal that I have the option to self-host.

Most likely, QoS would be better from ente's hosting and I would be inclined to take advantage of that. An open source server can be audited and offer an off-ramp should their service no longer suit me.

Then again, the economics of enabling self-hosted infrastructure are probably less exciting compared to locking users in to marked-up, white-labeled infrastructure.

Re:Show HN: We built an end-to-end encrypted alternative to ... by user-the-name on Sunday August 29, 2021 @12:01PM (#28347801)
How do you know it's zero knowledge?
Re:Show HN: We built an end-to-end encrypted alternative to ... by YPPH on Sunday August 29, 2021 @12:03PM (#28347835)
The source code of the client-side apps appears to be available on GitHub. So if they're bluffing, it won't be too long until someone calls them out on it.
Re:Show HN: We built an end-to-end encrypted alternative to ... by TheRealPomax on Sunday August 29, 2021 @12:21PM (#28348016)
Without a fully described mechanism to confirm that the client you download is not compiled with additional code (i.e. without specifying exactly how the client is compiled, using which version of which compiler, and which compile flags, dependency versions, etc) any kind of "the code seems to be on github" is kind of meaningless.
Re:Show HN: We built an end-to-end encrypted alternative to ... by dane-pgp on Sunday August 29, 2021 @01:28PM (#28348670)
Ideally they should support reproducible builds so that anyone can confirm that the hash of the app corresponds to a specific tag on the source repository. Unfortunately app stores are making it harder to know what the hash of the app you are installing is, but for side-loading this should still be possible.

For web apps, the situation is even more difficult, but there is a technique called Secure Bookmarks which allows you to confirm that a specific bundle of JavaScript is running (at the expense of some usability):

https://coins.github.io/secure-bookmark/

Re:Show HN: We built an end-to-end encrypted alternative to ... by ignoramous on Sunday August 29, 2021 @03:02PM (#28349497)
F-Droid supports reproducible builds. Any serious FOSS app, I think, must priortise publishing to F-Droid.
Re:Show HN: We built an end-to-end encrypted alternative to ... by user-the-name on Sunday August 29, 2021 @12:18PM (#28347976)
Unless they only send compromised code to you personally and nobody else.
Re:Show HN: We built an end-to-end encrypted alternative to ... by dane-pgp on Sunday August 29, 2021 @01:53PM (#28348877)
One way to mitigate that is through Binary Transparency, which would allow people to detect if a release is made for which there is no source code available (assuming the project already has reproducible builds). There is already a project attempting this for Arch Linux packages[0].

Of course it's still possible that an update could be sent to everyone which contains some code that only runs when a certain username is entered, so users would need to avoid updating the app until an audit by a trusted third party had approved it.

[0] https://github.com/kpcyrd/pacman-bintrans

Re:Show HN: We built an end-to-end encrypted alternative to ... by mynameismon on Sunday August 29, 2021 @12:03PM (#28347833)
Re:Show HN: We built an end-to-end encrypted alternative to ... by user-the-name on Sunday August 29, 2021 @12:19PM (#28347990)
That's just a non-binding promise. If that's enough for you, you don't need encryption at all.
Re:Show HN: We built an end-to-end encrypted alternative to ... by commoner on Sunday August 29, 2021 @01:10PM (#28348500)
I think the correct link is: https://ente.io/architecture
Re:Show HN: We built an end-to-end encrypted alternative to ... by user-the-name on Sunday August 29, 2021 @03:13PM (#28349586)
Again, just a promise.
Re:Show HN: We built an end-to-end encrypted alternative to ... by lol1lol on Sunday August 29, 2021 @11:50AM (#28347662)
self hosting is not worth the time and effort.
Re:Show HN: We built an end-to-end encrypted alternative to ... by andrewmunsell on Sunday August 29, 2021 @11:55AM (#28347723)
That is not categorically true.

On the business side, there's plenty of companies that have offered and succeeded with self-hosted software. On the client side, there's many individuals like myself willing to dedicate time, money, and effort to self-host services. I spent quite a bit of time setting up my NAS with self-hosted services, not only because the number of photos and media I store would be prohibitively expensive to host elsewhere (I do photography and videography as a hobby, 120 fps 10 bit footage adds up), but because I enjoy the hobby.

Re:Show HN: We built an end-to-end encrypted alternative to ... by lol1lol on Sunday August 29, 2021 @11:56AM (#28347747)
we have so many consumer facing apps. you'd want to maintain all those and actually have a life to use those? good luck!
Re:Show HN: We built an end-to-end encrypted alternative to ... by necovek on Tuesday August 31, 2021 @04:59PM (#28373587)
Not everybody has to use "many" apps. You can only self-host those you care about.