Re:My love-hate affair with technology
by elliekelly on Friday August 27, 2021 @12:12PM
(#28329586)
Amen. The law needs to change to require informed user consent.
More than that.
When manufacturers were letting rat poop get into the ketchup, we didn't create the FDA to make sure that "rat poop" was clearly printed on the label.
Re:My love-hate affair with technology
by yashasolutions on Friday August 27, 2021 @08:58PM
(#28334587)
brilliant way to put it
What would it change? I can't think of anyone from my immediate family who would ever not give permission to a popup that requested it.
GDPR tried to do that, and the governments charged to enforce it decided to not enforce it. It is one of the primary reason why there are people saying that only a few single digit percent of websites actually comply with GDPR, and why consent popup that most sites use do not actually conform to the law.
For sure. I was still glad to see it though; I think there's a lot of pressure for laws and policies to be exact, but honestly, in the very-quickly-moving world of tech, we should actually -- ha, fail early and often, even when it comes to policy.
Re:My love-hate affair with technology
by hammyhavoc on Sunday August 29, 2021 @11:13AM
(#28347350)
Seeing such passion rekindles my faith in the world.
How do you feel about software licensing, then? GPL and BSD licenses are certainly too long and heady for the "average joe" to understand when installing software, yet they're an essential part of software freedom. Are they also being exploitative, since they're subjecting the user to conditions they're unaware of?
IANL but just installing and using GPL software is not subjecting the user to any exploitative conditions. Only if the user tries to create a derivative work (linking) and redistribute that.
IAAL and yep :)
This notion is UTTER B.S. and needs to die quickly, and it is wholly unfair to put this on the users and not the creators and big companies.
(Yes, I am lawyer, and it is absolutely immoral to abuse our notions of contract law in this fashion. Gives the whole system a very bad name.)