I am not insisting that people should all earn the same amount of money. CEOs can absolutely provide a unique and valuable role and have more direct influence on shareholder value than almost any other laborer.
I am insisting that attributing all of the change in a stock price to a CEO is not an accurate representation of their role or labor.
That's just obviously not the case unless Tim is the only person working at Apple. All employees contributed that and it's perfectly reasonable to discuss how these rewards should be distributed, even if they should be distributed to shareholders at all.
The argument isn't that he should be paid less, the real argument is that the general day to day employees should be paid more. The money doesn't come out of the CEOs pocket in a publicly traded org.
To be honest, I wouldn't even blink if he was paid 10 times more, and I don't even like him.
Or another way to see it. While creating 2 trillion dollars of value for shareholders, he has been paid about 1.5 b. As a shareholder I think that’s very fair compensation.
So relative to value creation, nobody can claim that he’s overpaid. A deeper questions is if it’s reasonable for anyone to own a billion dollars. I don’t think so, but Tim Cook has deserved the money more than most.