Obviously that didn't work for income tax, and I would go even further to argue the feds should not be paid one bit of direct tax.
When the feds collect money and disperse it to the states, the states become enslaved to the federal government and loose their sovereignty. More importantly, without this sovereignty there is no competition or experimentation amongst the states.
I like the idea elsewhere on the thread of standardizing a database to enable the calculation to be readily done by the seller (and those places with systems so complex that they can't be represented with a couple of fields - state, tax level, exceptions - can just lose out).
[1] pg can we please have some more space between the up and down vote buttons for touch screens?
To make my point differently and maybe to make it more tech specific:
I would rather pay individual companies for software I want to run on my PC than to pay Microsoft a lump sum and have them give me a bunch of software they think I need (and then distribute the funds to the creators how they see fit).
It could be argued that it would be easier for consumers to pay only Microsoft, saving them the headache of creating relationships with multiple vendors.
Or it could be argued that the chaos of the market is worth the competition that ultimately benefits the consumer.
I like the bottom up approach because it creates competition and choice.
And thus my point. I live in MA, where it's legal, and the world didn't end and God didn't smite us. This "experiment", if done at the federal level, wouldn't have happened for another decade because the country is still split.
Now people can point to MA and say, see this works. Gay marriage laws are literally spreading from MA outward.
So, if you're gay move to MA, if you're appalled by the idea move out. If you're of Hispanic decent move away from Arizona. If you don't like super irresponsible government spending, move out of California. Either way, you're still an American and you have choice.
Regardless of today's law, I am currently of the opinion that direct taxes should be collected at the most local level possible with each community paying it's parent an apportioned amount for the service, privileged, and protection it provides.
I think it's good to let the individual places set their own tax rates as long as there's a way to take the burden off web retailers. For example, a city might have a tax on tire sales to help fund road upgrades. Online tire retailers shouldn't be able to skip out on the tax since the tires are going to be used on the roads the city is upgrading.
I'm sure that it's completely possible to track all the tax-specific details that you mention, and I know it's already being done (Amazon ran Target.com which has full 50-state coverage and did collect sales taxes everywhere).
If it's mandated, there will be an opportunity to sell this service to retailers... though I do agree that a single federal % number would be more feasible, it will never happen.
Also, what about foreign companies? We already know that sales tax has kept digital companies out of states with sales tax could this encourage such companies to move to Canada or Mexico? Next when I buy a purely digital good this work? Do you use my current location or my billing address?
Don't get me wrong, I would love to see something like this come to pass, so you'll have to excuse my cynicism (no doubt brought on by current events).
I understand the desire to eliminate the tax advantage internet retailers currently have, but I think it would be better solved by a federal sales tax (either directly or indirectly disbursed to states) than by forcing retailers to hire a team of tax accountants to keep up with thousands of sets of sales tax laws.