Re:Toshiba reports milestone in quantum cryptography
by tinco on Thursday August 26, 2021 @05:55PM
(#28321448)
I don't know why someone downvoted you, but the flaw people are pointing out is that the initial agreeing upon a basis is equivalent to exchanging a preshared key. If you've got a preshared key, then why go through the trouble of setting up a QKD for sending PSK's? There's bound to be good reasons, but you're comment doesn't address this.
- They have a 50% chance of measuring in the correct basis and re-sending the proper qubit - They have a 50% change of measuring in the incorrect basis, in which case their measurement means nothing and the qubit they send is in a superposition in the correct basis, leading to a chance Bob measures the wrong value
Over a very long string, it becomes exponentially unlikely that the MITM could guess the proper basis and then re-send the proper qubit to Bob. As that binary string grows in length, it's essentially impossible to MITM with any meaningful likelihood.