The man is simply harmful, tho [1]. His methods promote aggressive approach where you take control by threatening your dog with your body language.
[1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ppLnTlF8s0k (huge number of dislikes, but talk to anybody who works with dogs professionally)
Someone i really look up to is Vanessa Bokr owner of the https://www.hellhound-foundation.com:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fQijH4vvDMo
Sorry for being just in german.
It just seems like it is likely to make the dog see that as a way of trying to assert dominance, whereas in almost all other cases positive reinforcement (and negative attention from undesired attention) seems to be perfectly adequate.
Perhaps it’s only supposed to be something for the worst-case untrained dogs and has spread out from there?
Bunny, of YouTube and tiktok fame, has demonstrated remarkably abstract thoughts, and the fart/poop humor [1] was a revelation to me. Dogs are treated like automata or mindless things, but they are intelligent and emotional on a very human level.
Giving them voices and making such systems common and easy would radically change humanity's relationship with canines for the better.
https://youtu.be/9iW1CY7mlOI