There is a conflation between "correlatives" (a privilege means that no-one else has a claim to prevent you from exercising the privilege, whereas if you have a claim, then someone has the duty to fulfill it) and enforcement which requires state intervention.
Human Rights are a kind of schelling points where we agree that "those roles are so Universal that as soon as we recognize a violation of them, we instantly recognize who is the Bad Guy (the one who is violating them) and who is the Good Guy and (the one who is denied his basic human rights) and EVERYTHING GOES to fix the situation". If you have to put a bullet in the head of the Bad Guy, so be it. If you say that "Housing is a Human Right", you are instantly obligated to donate all of your disposable income as soon as you encounter one homeless. If you don’t, well, any bystander is justified in taking it from you, by force if necessary.
By putting everything that sounds nice in "Human Rights", you cheapen the term. Let’s say that in 20 years Human Rights really means exactly that : housing, basic income, internet access, and so on. In the mind of everyone, Human Right violation is no big deal, like someone not having internet access. Then how do you communicate the horrors of innocent citizens getting arrested, tortured and murdered ? Are you really going to put those two realities in the same term, "Human Rights Violation" ?
I'd like to understand how you would rank competing human rights for example? What if my human right to healthcare conflicts with your human right to not be forced to work? What if my right to have somewhere to live (for travellers, actual legal case in the UK) conflicts with your human right to own property and not have it invaded? What if my human right to not cover my face conflicts with your human right to a "germ and virus free environment".
Do you create a hierarchy of rights? Once you do that, how are they different from laws? You've just created lots of laws at this point for different people and situations.
In my world those are not rights any more. They're bullshit. A right is something, theoretically, that everyone can have. Conflicting rights by definition destroy that.
Your rights stop when someone else's rights are infringed. But where exactly do you draw the line? This is a complex and time-dependent question with a case-by-case answer. Right now, the human right to live outweighs the human right to not cover your face. In the EU, the right to privacy prevails the right of companies to serve targeted ads -- although the discussion around legitimate interests is ongoing.
Human rights are stuff like the right to dignity, the right of to being compelled to work, the right of not being totured or wrongfully imprisoned.
Humans right are supposed to only include those where you do not need to weight opposing rights. If person A is being tortured that is always a violation of a human right and it is never a violation of a human right not to torture sombody.
Humans right are meant to be a baseline definition of what we must provide to every human on the planet in any situation, whether there is a surplus of food or a worldwide famine, whether we live is a super advance technocracy or a solar flare destroys all electronics.
There are many many rights that are deeply essential in our society that are not human rights
I could probably come up with a situation for each right that feels absolute.
I am also reclutant to include it as a human right, the corresponding human right would be "freedom not to be compelled to express" eg freedom not to be forced to profess beliefs you do not want to profess.
Personally I do not believe that screaming at people and relentlessly insulting them is a human right, nor that doing so is necessarily a damage to their dignity so I do not see a contraddiction.
Consider property rights. I rent. My landlord has never stepped foot in the house. The state enforces his property rights. But the way it would do that is by violently evicting me from the property and making me homeless.
The state needs to actively physically move my body in order to protect the property that is owned by somebody else because they wrote a contract. Is that a negative right?
It’s their home because somebody bought the land, put in the effort to build the home, and then either decided to rent it out or decided to trade it to someone who earned the money to buy the home.
> The state needs to actively physically move my body in order to protect the property that is owned by somebody else because they wrote a contract
No, the state needs to actively physically move your body because you are breaking the contract that you signed by not vacating the home after your lease ends, and in doing so, you are violating the property rights of the homeowner.
This perspective taken to its natural conclusion would imply that homes are built on trees (pun intended, they are made of wood).
Cool.
This then does not cleanly describe a negative right. The state is not preventing some action from being done, ensuring that people have access to the body and possessions as granted by the universe. Instead, it is taking action to change something about the world (I am currently possessing the house) based on an entirely human construct (a contract).
Living in someone's house against their will, and without their contractual agreement, does not a possessor make. The state is preventing theft, essentially. Claiming something that belongs to somebody else as your own is theft. It doesn't matter if what you're stealing is small enough that it fits in your hand, or big enough that you can walk inside it.
> ensuring that people have access to the body and possessions as granted by the universe
If you think it's the universe that built the house and that's why it should be free for anyone to take, that's the core of the problem as I mentioned above. It's like you believe houses grow on trees.
> This then does not cleanly describe a negative right.
The negative right here is that you are not entitled to property. You are not entitled to property, whether land or items, for free. You have to acquire it without breaking other people's right to their property. You have to trade for it (we've invented money as a means of doing this efficiently, so we can work and then trade the money to builders, or the person who previously owned it and hired the builders).
To sum it up: The right to property is a negative right, a "right to property" as a positive right would be government entitlement to some amount of land.
Life is much messier than just negotiating rights, so please don't take my dismissal of your conflict of rights argument as a claim that life is a walk in the park.
But the issue that makes it messy is almost always not any conflict of negative rights, which outside of a tiny number of edge cases dealing with the limits of what defines a person's legitimate claims (e.g. the legitimacy of national sovereignty and the rights citizens inherit from that, the co-use of public property like roads and the rules that govern that, and the rules that assign private property rights over what is arguably public property, like private ownership over scarce natural resources) they are nowhere close to conflicting, and can be understood within a consistent moral framework adopted from thousands of years of theological evolution and moral philosophy, culminating in legal and moral principles like substantive due process, and the Golden Rule, respectively.
Unless you’re saying that somehow it’s impossible for a society like the UK or US to ensure everyone has access to the above?
Even for your “negative rights”, we today already have conflicts. For instance, a right to trial by a jury of your peers: this clearly conflicts with the jury’s right to work. They can’t work while they’re hearing your trial. As soon as you allow “we’ll just dismiss those for whom jury duty is an undue burden”, you’re acknowledging society is big enough to handle these conflicts without creating an undue burden on anyone.
Under this definition, what would you consider a right?
See Lozito vs. NYC - an individual was attacked by a drug addict with a knife. In front of 2 cops. They did nothing until the victim subdued the attacker. They then did not try to render aid to the victim. When Lozito sued, the judge dismissed saying the police have no duty to protect anyone.
Many marginalized communities realize the state is not there to help or serve them. If your experience is different - it is most likely that it is more of a happy coincidence that the state's interests and your personal interests are temporarily in alignment. There is no guarantees that this will continue for any length of time.
First, this is voluntary labor. The 'forced labor' is with the taxpayer that pays for this being done.
Second, a state enforcing rights is rather different from human rights. If the state doesn't enforce a human right then that doesn't mean it's not a human right anymore. You didn't forfeit your right to life just because Pol Pot came into power, did you?
The state enforcing a right is one way to resolve a conflict of somebody violating your rights, but it's not the only one. If somebody attacks you and intends to kill you, then you can defend yourself with deadly force. Society doesn't pursue you for violating the attacker's right to life. Society doesn't have to do any work in this case, but the violation was dealt with.
Also, the human right to free speech doesn't mean that anybody has to listen to you or to promote what you're saying. Nobody has to give you a platform. Now, you could have a separate right to free speech that's a right given by the state (a law) that forces a social media site to give you (anyone) a platform, but that would be separate from human rights.
If a human right requires somebody else's labor then you have an adequacy problem. At what point is the human right fulfilled? If the government treats only broken bones, then is the right being fulfilled? Do they have to give you that million dollar gene therapy? Is the government violating your human rights because it doesn't invest enough into healthcare research for future treatments?
What if you fail to defend yourself?
On July 25, 2013, Judge Margaret Chan dismissed Lozito's suit, stating that while Lozito's account of the attack rang true and appeared "highly credible", Chan agreed that police had "no special duty" to protect Lozito.
(Edit: spelling)
I'm not sure how this relates to the conversation about rights. To talk about the inclusion of Healthcare as a right for instance, no one would propose that the government prevent people from getting injured. Or to, while being injured, intervene and stop it. My understanding is that healthcare provided as a right would be healthcare provided in response to an injury a Citizen has experienced.
Getting internet or health care is more of an expectation of citizenship.
In the Netherlands you're legally only allowed to use enough the minimum amount of violence necessary in self defense. You're obligated to flee if possible. So if a frail lady in a wheelchair comes at you with a knife, you can't stand your ground and kick her bony ass.
Indeed, so as long as we can agree that the government paying for labor does not constitute forced labor, we can dispel the false premise that the state employing medical care providers is somehow forced labor. I was working under that premise (phrasing framework?) to prove the point that even within that framework the logic does not hold, but I'm glad you acknowledge, and we can agree, it is not accurate.
> The 'forced labor' is with the taxpayer that pays for this being done.
(assuming you are a US citizen) No one forces you to pay taxes; I believe there are large quantities of homeless persons who do not own land and do not participate in labor compensated by currency and are also not subject to taxation. You and I would probably agree that a person should be able to buy land and provide for themselves without taxation (and that this is currently not possible to my knowledge under our current system) but that does not mean the existence of taxation equates to forced labor. It is just very close, and practically speaking how it ends up being for most people who wish to live lives interconnected to society.
> Second, a state enforcing rights is rather different from human rights. If the state doesn't enforce a human right then that doesn't mean it's not a human right anymore. You didn't forfeit your right to life just because Pol Pot came into power, did you?
Having a right which is incapable of being defended is in a practical sense identical to not having that right. What material changes in circumstance occur where one "Has a right but can't enforce it's expression" and where one "Doesn't have the right"? And if there is no material change in circumstance, is there some benefit beyond that which I am not considering?
>Also, the human right to free speech doesn't mean that anybody has to listen to you or to promote what you're saying. Nobody has to give you a platform. Now, you could have a separate right to free speech that's a right given by the state (a law) that forces a social media site to give you (anyone) a platform, but that would be separate from human rights.
If we have a divergence between human rights and rights "given to you by the state (a law)" then there is no point in discussing human rights. The only worthwhile rights are the ones the state is willing to give; legal rights which have an impact on your material circumstances while alive on this planet. Beyond the scope of the law you are free to determine which rights you think are/are not human rights and the rest of the population can either ignore them or accommodate based on how willing they believe you are to try and enforce them.
There is not purpose to having a broader discussion of human rights under your framework, as enforcement is not part of the equation. Why must we agree on what a human right is if there is no enforcement of one side or the other?
The purpose of discussion on human rights should be to determine the scope of enforcement once rights are agreed upon.
> If a human right requires somebody else's labor then you have an adequacy problem.
Correct, and we face this problem constantly in relation to all rights enforced by the government.
> At what point is the human right fulfilled? If the government treats only broken bones, then is the right being fulfilled?
Presumably yes if the citizens have agreed upon a Right to Mend Broken Bones.
> Do they have to give you that million dollar gene therapy?
Presumably yes if the citizens have agreed upon a Right to Million Dollar Gene Therapy.
> Is the government violating your human rights because it doesn't invest enough into healthcare research for future treatments?
Probably not, as we don't typically operate under the framework of the right to have something which does not exist. Future treatments do not exist in the present, and would be incapable of being provided as a right in the present.
I think it's a great idea for governments to invest in the development of future treatments, and when they are discovered perhaps then it would make sense to provide as a right, but not until they exist.
It takes active effort for the government to infringe in this case. It's actually quite tiresome, requiring people to round up the satanists, and root them out. Oppression can be pretty expensive.
Then you have things like safety, security, and prosperity. I share the view that these things aren't rights. I still view things like free speech and exercise of religion as "rights", and not things like food. That doesn't make them unimportant or mean the government shouldn't try to stop people from dying. Why does something have to be a right for the government to get involved. Why water down the concept of rights, by making them about access to resources? Using government isn't a two step process, where first something must be classified as a right, then the government can act.
The role of government in these cases is very different from the first example. There they simply needed to not use resources for oppression (it's not always THAT simple, but some things really do require active effort). Now they need to ensure everyone is getting adequate resources. It's fundamentally a different concept.
> You only get to exercise the right to free speech if everyone else knows there are consequences for disrupting it. (Fines, imprisonment, etc)... you only have that freedom so long as someone more powerful than you doesn't feel like taking it from you.
You're describing the government protecting you from a third party, which is not usually how first amendment laws are used in the USA (USA is just an example here). So no, active resources aren't necessarily needed to protect free speech infringement from government. Not in the same way as with resource allocation. Yeah, courts exist, but the health of a court system is not necessarily related to resources allocated. You could have a really well funded court that rubber stamps everything.
I actually think there's an interesting conversation here, regarding trade-offs between freedom/rights and prosperity/health. You could live in a totally free society with no food and health care, but what would be the point? Or you could live in an oppressive state, devoid of human dignity, but be perfectly healthy and safe. Maybe rights and freedom are a bit overrated.
How much does it cost to not arrest and try someone falsely?
There are situations where the injustice is the thing that requires taxes and government.
> You only get to exercise the right to free speech if everyone else knows there are consequences for disrupting it. (Fines, imprisonment, etc)
Consequences don't have to run through the criminal justice system. If some people are assaulted, they are allowed to defend themselves. The damage done to assailants in the process is tax-free.
EDIT: Besides, rights are rights whether they are enforced or not. Slavery is still a violation of rights even when it is legal.
But how about those who don't exist in this wild west cowboy world of duels at noon for honor? How do children defend themselves? How do the weak and infirm? Because they are incapable of enforcing their own rights they lose them? How do you stop mob justice? These don't sound like rights at all if you need to personally fight to ensure that you can keep them.
For everyone else, I believe the answer you are looking for is: guns. Everyone exists in this world, whether willingly or not. If someone is unwilling to defend their self, then that is their problem, and hopefully not the problem of others.
At minimum enough to arbitrate claims of the opposite occurring.
You are correct in stating proper adherence to this right will not cost much (if there were ever a theoretical group of people who could agree on what "arrest falsely" meant every time) but merely acknowledging that some amount of resource must be spent should be enough to put to rest the idea that there are a special set of "negative rights" which require no resources to maintain and therefore are the only Real Rights while the others are the Made Up Rights.
> rights are rights whether they are enforced or not.
I think this may be where our primary disagreement exists. From my perspective a right is relatively useless to establish if enforcement does not accompany said right. You can inform the slave that he has a right to no longer live under subjugation, but if he has no mechanism by which to escape his slavery without loss of life his material conditions do not change.
If your argument is that rights exclusively provide the framework for a defense of violent revolution (as this is the only use I can imagine them having without accompanied enforcement) I would still argue for the inclusion of more rights as the capacity of the state expands, as that would be the primary tool by which Citizens can protect themselves against exploitation.
There is value in people knowing a slave has intrinsic worth and deserves freedom. People deserve justice especially when it is out of reach.
Then there is no reason to discuss rights at all since might makes right.
An all powerful despot can still be a rapist and murderer.
And as a European this makes me sad. I hate living somewhere where most people believe government allows them to do things rather than tells them what not to do. It’s a small difference but it’s important.
Anyone from the Balkans here? :)
Every government program, every preservation of right, requires taxation and resource allocation. Unless you are advocating for the complete dissolution of government we are merely talking of degrees.
There is always a specific debate to be had around each degree of power and influence the government is granted. But if you refuse to acknowledge the reality that people are "forced" into compliance for all rights, including those you deem 'negative', it's impossible to even discuss.
You only get to exercise the right to free speech if everyone else knows there are consequences for disrupting it. (Fines, imprisonment, etc)
If no one is willing or able to act as the enforcement arm of the state, you only have that freedom so long as someone more powerful than you doesn't feel like taking it from you. That requires the 'forced' labor of police officers, prison guards, construction workers for the prisons, agricultural workers for the food, medical supplies manufacturers, medical staff members for prisons, electricians, plumbers, garbage, sanitation workers. I'm sure if I spent more than a minute I could think of more, but just understanding the scope of labor required to enforce one 'negative right' should help illustrate why this line of conversation is a complete waste of time.