News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Human Rights Are Not a Bug by dang on Thursday August 26, 2021 @07:54PM (#28322571)
Please omit nationalistic flamebait from your posts to HN, regardless of which nation you have a problem with. It leads to nationalistic flamewars, which are tedious and nasty so we don't want them here. Instead, please make your substantive points thoughtfully.

Your comment would be fine without the first paragraph.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Human Rights Are Not a Bug by fennecfoxen on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @09:07AM (#28301166)
It seems likely that you don't believe in the rights, the negative individual rights, that these Americans believe in; rather, you are willing to subordinate them to a cause which you believe is a good cause. (It might even be a good cause in fact.)

If this is the case, then it is "tiresome" because, old as these ideas are, they are working exactly as intended: they are presenting a stumbling block to your utopian designs. Modern history is full of movements promising utopias by systematically violating human rights.

Re:Human Rights Are Not a Bug by throwaway34241 on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @11:10AM (#28302622)
> It seems likely that you don't believe in the rights, the negative individual rights, that these Americans believe in

I’m probably also on the other side of this issue, but my take is a bit nuanced here. The government keeps the cost of healthcare high via a myriad of factors (long approval processes, requiring overtraining (years of calculus etc) for many tasks that don’t require it, having a certificate of need required to open a hospital, centrally planning the number of doctors via number of medicare funded residency slots, etc).

I think there is a moral case for a negative-rights oriented Milton Friedman style libertarian state that also addresses those issues (although even Friedman made a concession to utilitarian concerns with his negative income tax).

But there doesn’t seem to be a major US political faction making that case, or willing to spend the political capital or do the advocacy required to get there to any significant degree. Instead, the debate is mostly over the tax rates. I feel focusing primarily on the subsidies without the radical deregulation produces a system that is neither particularly libertarian or utilitarian, although it serves the interests of some fraction of voters.

> Modern history is full of movements promising utopias

You may be surprised but I agree pretty strongly here on the dangers of utopianism. I suspect where we differ is I view the movement to go back before the welfare state as in itself utopian. I think it is putting rose-colored glasses on the political economy of the industrial revolution, when that system fell to various forms of authoritarianism all over the world. In my view we would be better off with a political faction that accepted the fundamental logic of the welfare state while attempting to minimize the regulatory burden, although at this point it’s hard to see how we get there from here.

[dead]
Re:Human Rights Are Not a Bug by lowkey_ on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @09:35AM (#28301485)
While you may disagree with the parent comment's assessment, I don't see a logic where you can agree with Americans on their 1776-era negative rights and argue that human rights should include a lot of positive rights.

If you're not willing to subordinate negative rights, then how can you claim positive rights as human rights? As someone validly mentioned, they are directly at odds with one another.

[dead]
Re:Human Rights Are Not a Bug by lowkey_ on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @09:58AM (#28301748)
> It seems likely that you don't believe in the rights, the negative individual rights, that these Americans believe in; rather, you are willing to subordinate them to a cause which you believe is a good cause. (It might even be a good cause in fact. > If this is the case, then it is "tiresome" because, old as these ideas are, they are working exactly as intended: they are presenting a stumbling block to your utopian designs. Modern history is full of movements promising utopias by systematically violating human rights.

That comment directly applies to this situation and proves it. You're against property rights (a negative individual right) for a 'good cause' (anti-racism), and in favor of letting it be subordinate to positive rights.

A history of property rights being 'tied' to racism doesn't mean that we should repeal or lessen property rights; we should ensure property rights apply to everyone. The only issue with America's human rights was that they were not equally applied to everyone.

My ancestors were essentially enslaved for several hundred years and now my grandmother, father, and mother all own a bit of property. We won't be letting anyone take that, or any part of property rights, away from us. I appreciate that you're in favor of this for a noble reason but nobody needs a savior to take away others' rights.

Re:Human Rights Are Not a Bug by brnt on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @10:15AM (#28301961)
You decontextualize my statement into a categorical disregard of negative rights. That proves nothing, just that you did not consider the context and limitation of the incursion. Or that you didn't consider one of the other points, the inevitable balancing of rights that needs to take place in any system of rights.

You can't simplify this sort of issue, you fundamentally can't. Not every nuance is a slippery slope.

Re:Human Rights Are Not a Bug by lowkey_ on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @09:30AM (#28301414)
> based on the simple premise that the human condition continues to evolve

The human condition under government continues to involve, but we as humans are largely the same.

These positive rights, such as entitlement to x provided by y and z, are more like citizens' rights than human rights.

A human right is something that every human is entitled to, regardless of their citizenship, or even not having a citizenship. Human rights don't include tax-funded services that comes with living in a first-world country. They are rights that all humans can and deserve to have, and should be un-infringed upon with regards to.

Re:Human Rights Are Not a Bug by SketchySeaBeast on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @09:55AM (#28301708)
> They are rights that all humans can and deserve to have, and should be un-infringed upon with regards to.

I guess in that case we have to assume we have very few actual rights. Being jailed for a crime is the removal of many of what people would consider fundamental rights (eg. the right to travel freely).

Re:Human Rights Are Not a Bug by sershe on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @10:58PM (#28310108)
If the rights are construed as an (implied) social contract of negative rights, this is easy to resolve. If you uphold the social contract towards others, you are implicitly agreeing to be bound by it, and others who likewise agree owe you your part. If you violate others' negative rights you, again implicitly, reject that social contract. Therefore, others don't owe you anything, your rights can also be violated.

I personally subscribe to what I view as a more logically consistent version where the only thing that matter is how confident we are that someone rejects the social contract. If e.g. they repeatedly keep committing clear-cut crimes against clear-cut victims, they obviously think it doesn't apply to them, and in my view they literally should have no more human rights than a rock. That should apply whether they are a CEO defrauding customers, or a homeless person stealing a bike.

However, most people think it's a proportional/gradual kind of thing, hence e.g. jail.

Re:Human Rights Are Not a Bug by SketchySeaBeast on Thursday August 26, 2021 @09:12AM (#28314456)
Even your definition has some problems though - how much is "repeatedly" and what's the level of "clear-cut"? And does everyone's rights immediately go to zero with "no more human rights than a rock"? We can sell both a homeless person who steals a bike or a CEO who defrauds millions for millions both into slavery? Do they regain those rights at some point, or should a juvenile delinquent be sent to the mining camps never to return? There's a lot of nuance required for this stuff, and I don't know if we can draw a line in the sand where people become pond scum.
Re:Human Rights Are Not a Bug by sershe on Friday August 27, 2021 @01:18PM (#28330471)
The distinction I was trying to make is that most people take a gradual approach to this contract, even if they don't articulate it, i.e. they say "you robbed a gas station, [so you are 15% "pond scum" and 85% not, so we are going to take 15% of your rights away, ] so we are going to jail you for a year", or "you killed this family and ate the bodies, [so you are 90% "pond scum", so we are going to take 90% of your rights away, ] so we are going to execute you".

I think the problem is actually uncertainty. If someone robbed a gas station, it's not that they broke the social contract N% of the way and are N% "pond scum"; it's that we are about N% sure that they are 100% "pond scum". So, before we are sure enough, they have full rights and we should try to re-integrate them and not punish them beyond fixing the damage, and after we are sure enough (which may be on the 5th bike, 3rd gas station, or the 1st rape), they have no rights and yeah, it's e.g. mines/lethal injection.

Either way it responds to the original objection... punishment/retaliation works fine with negative-only rights.

Re:Human Rights Are Not a Bug by zpeti on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @09:00AM (#28301075)
Laws should not be mechanical. I agree. That’s what they are for.

Human rights by definition should. Of course they haven’t been for a long time.

I’m not American btw. Just someone who understands how ridiculously fragile our current political system is.

Re:Human Rights Are Not a Bug by brnt on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @09:07AM (#28301162)
> Human rights by definition should.

What basis exists for us being able to claim that we have arrived at the final set of rights sufficient to describe what a human needs to be free?

Re:Human Rights Are Not a Bug by dudul on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @09:09AM (#28301198)
Rights don't describe what you need to be free, they just say that you do have the right to be free. Then laws are put in place to try to protect your right.
Re:Human Rights Are Not a Bug by brnt on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @09:13AM (#28301235)
I thought we were discussing human rights, and therefore I use text of the Declaration. This text is certainly more specific than stating that humans are free. It also describes positive rights, for one.
Re:Human Rights Are Not a Bug by zpeti on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @09:10AM (#28301206)
If one human or group of humans can’t force another to do something, that is freedom. It’s pretty simple really.
Re:Human Rights Are Not a Bug by brnt on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @09:16AM (#28301274)
> It’s pretty simple really.

I can only conclude that you continue to not inform yourself of any discussion on the subject. I've never heard anyone serious describe rights as 'pretty simple'. Advocates of reducing rights to a limited and for them convenient set, yes, but that is precisely the challenge.

Re:Human Rights Are Not a Bug by SketchySeaBeast on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @10:02AM (#28301825)
That sounds like lawlessness. I can't get punished when I violate rights because that would be an infringement on my rights, so there's no encouragement by me or anyone else to respect rights.
Re:Human Rights Are Not a Bug by dudul on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @09:10AM (#28301213)
I'm sure the 1st paragraph of your comment will guarantee a serein and cordial conversation.
Re:Human Rights Are Not a Bug by throwawaylinux on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @09:25AM (#28301347)
If "the thinking" was not so clearly only interested in rights that happen to align with certain world views and tended to ignore the inconvenient ones, that might be a good argument.

One of the most important human rights is the right to have the right to self-determination, to choose how they are governed and what laws they live under. However when a majority of people in a country have an opinion that is deemed problematic by certain self-proclaimed human rights enthusiasts, it is attacked as "populist" or slandered as being against human rights!

Human rights are wonderful. Human Rights™ has been hijacked and twisted and politicized just like everything else.