Re:Human Rights Are Not a Bug
by ChrisSD on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @08:51AM
(#28300977)
Say I try to force you to do something. Who is to stop me doing that? It requires government and taxation to run a justice system. I.e. a ton of "energy".
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Enforcing rights takes energy, but respecting them takes none.
Laws, and legally created rights, are far too complicated and numerous for mere respect to be enough. This is why corporate lawyers exist, and why trade unions can win things for employees without having to go as far as a strike.
Ignorance of the law must not be an excuse, but it definitely can be the actual cause.
Re:Human Rights Are Not a Bug
by contravariant on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @10:03AM
(#28301835)
Well in that case we can at least all agree to respect human rights in the broad sense. As doing so wouldn't cost any energy and so wouldn't be in conflict with the 'negative' right or anti-duty that OP is talking about.
[dead]
Re:Human Rights Are Not a Bug
by SketchySeaBeast on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @09:49AM
(#28301641)
If you're not packing heat you can't expect your rights to be observed? Man, orphan babies are screwed.
Re:Human Rights Are Not a Bug
by anticristi on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @09:52AM
(#28301679)
Also: Women in Kabul. :(
> Who is to stop me doing that?
me.
Re:Human Rights Are Not a Bug
by SketchySeaBeast on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @09:29AM
(#28301406)
... Batman?
It's a great exercise to see if you can come up with a system that can function to provide such safety in a voluntary manner. I would argue it's possible. Definitely not easy, though. But just because it's hard doesn't mean the answer is "government".
Well if we're talking hypotheticals then why not add a volunteer healthcare system? After all, if we can somehow manage a volunteer police force, judiciary, etc all without government then it should be possible to add healthcare to the mix.
In any case, my point was the distinction made in the OP is silly. Any "right" is only a right in so far as it can actually be put into practice and that costs someone, somewhere "energy".