Where I work we get enough mail bounces from customers whose mailboxes are over quota, or who spelled their address wrong, and so on that challenges from the few using C/R systems are lost in the noise. No one has time to go through all of these, find the challenges, and jump through whatever hoops they want to get the message through.
As a former tech/cust support worker, I hate challenge-response systems. The usual scene is this: (1) [email protected] gets an email (2) I respond via my address, [email protected] (3) I get a challenge-response email and have to jump through a bunch of hoops to get permission to email the bastard who initiated the exchange.
And perhaps some people think that whitelisting [email protected] is enough, when really they should whitelist the entire domain. It's common that email to a general address is parceled out to individuals.
http://a-s-k.sourceforge.net/
When some dastardly spammer adds me to their list, despite the challenge message explicitly telling them not to, I then add them to my "blacklist" and never hear from them again.
Note that you do have to be running your own mail server to get this system working; and you have to edit the lists from the command line. Those challenges aside, this software has eliminated vast quantities of spam and unwanted list mailings for me.