As an example, Heartland includes interchange in their revenue. "Heartland reported $526 million in gross revenues for the quarter... Interchange accounted for $365.2 million of second-quarter revenues."[1]
At Braintree we don't include interchange in our revenue, so our processing volume is higher than Square's, but our revenue is lower.
With their pricing scheme Square loses money on every transaction below ~$6 in size. They will make money for transactions between $6 and $15, will lose money between $15 and $18 and will make money on transactions larger than $18.
The reason for the weird discontinuity at $15 is that Visa cards and Mastercard Debit (but not Mastercard credit) cards have a special, lower, rate for small transactions called a small ticket rate. If you are a merchant with a very small average transaction size, you absolutely should use Square - their price is so low for those transactions they are losing money and subsidizing the user.
In reality, their average transaction is not as small as you'd think. It's actually ~$83 (some simple math from the screen Jack posted on his twitter), so they are making a good deal of money, but at much smaller margins than most people realize.
More details (assumptions, charts, etc): http://feefighters.com/blog/can-square-make-money-with-its-n...
Also relevant: Compare prices of Square vs. a traditional merchant account http://feefighters.com/square-calculator
To make matters worse, that 2% in interchange fees is an average across all credit card transactions. But most interchange agreements are "fixed fee + percent of transaction" and I suspect Square's average transaction is significantly smaller than the average credit card transaction. That would imply their cut is even smaller than the 0.75% that it would be otherwise.
On the plus side, at scale Square should be able to directly negotiate better interchange fees with issuing banks - but I'd be very surprised if they ever drop below 1% on average. It would be impressive (but possible, given Square's pull in the industry via Visa et al.), that they've already pulled off some agreement to that effect.