News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Razer bug lets you become a Windows 10 admin by plugging ... by MichaelGroves on Monday August 23, 2021 @02:11PM (#28279791)
> Third party devices do need automatic driver install of some form.

I don't see why. Particularly not if the user wouldn't have permissions to do it themselves. If the user doesn't have permission to install a driver, there is probably a good reason for it and the system shouldn't be automatically installing drivers on their behalf either.

Re:Razer bug lets you become a Windows 10 admin by plugging ... by ajross on Monday August 23, 2021 @02:53PM (#28280305)
You or I don't. But in the market, if you can't make your product work with no fuss, your customers will buy someone else's (or flee to another platform entirely).

If you accept the paradigm of third party hardware sales at all, then you need to have some kind of automatic secure install.

Re:Razer bug lets you become a Windows 10 admin by plugging ... by MichaelGroves on Monday August 23, 2021 @03:17PM (#28280644)
> if you can't make your product work with no fuss, your customers will buy someone else's

If Razor can't make their gamer mouse autoinstall drivers, then neither can Logitech. This would be an equal playing field.

> (or flee to another platform entirely).

If somebody can't type in their own password when prompted to install a driver, it probably isn't their computer in the first place. The computer almost certainly belongs to their school or employer, or at least another family member, and I think any of those would rarely be receptive to "Please replace your dell with a macbook because the turbo button on my gamer mouse doesn't work."

Furthermore, the gamer mouse will have basic functionality without the razor driver anyway, and from my experience I doubt most clueless computer users would notice the difference. If they can "click the internet button and the google shows up", then the mouse is working as far as most users of this sort are concerned.

Re:Razer bug lets you become a Windows 10 admin by plugging ... by andix on Tuesday August 24, 2021 @10:17AM (#28289152)
On Windows you don't even need to type in the password to install something. UAC just gives you a yes/no dialog. Most home users have the permissions for that.

Only if your user doesn't have admin permissions you need to type in a password to run something elevated.

Re:Razer bug lets you become a Windows 10 admin by plugging ... by rodgerd on Monday August 23, 2021 @06:13PM (#28282672)
Perhaps you long for the good old days where we carried around piles of floppies for our hardware, but I suspect you are in a small minority.
Re:Razer bug lets you become a Windows 10 admin by plugging ... by MichaelGroves on Monday August 23, 2021 @08:53PM (#28283942)
I'm not saying we should go back to floppies. A prompt for the administrator password followed by an otherwise automatic driver installation should be fine.